China loses another: Long March 3B launch fails and Palapa-N1 falls into the drink

by | Apr 9, 2020 | China, Launches, Satellites, Space Insurance

Having had a launch setback with its new Long March 7A (CZ-7A) rocket in March, it looked unlikely that China would have another launch failure so soon. And yet, on 9 April 2020, an improved version of its venerable Long March 3B-G2 launch vehicle failed while carrying the Palapa-N1 communications satellite.

An unusually bright transonic vapour cloud was briefly seen during the launch around the time of Max Q. Nevertheless, the flight seemed to go well after its lift-off at 1146 GMT from the Xichang launch site in China’s Sichuan province.

It was later revealed that the vehicle had suffered a third stage failure with the satellite and third stage not achieving orbital velocity, falling back to Earth and re-entering over the Pacific. There were subsequent sightings of re-entering debris from Guam and a supersonic bang was heard.

Debris from the failed Long March 3B launch of Palapa-N1 was seen re-entering over Guam. Courtesy: Weibo

The Palapa-N1 (aka Nusantara Dua) was a communications satellite built by CAST using its DFH-4E bus design, under a “turn-key” construction and delivery-to-orbit contract run by China Great Wall Industry Corp (CGWIC). The satellite was insured for US$252.5 million, with half covered on the world insurance market and the other half retained by the Chinese insurance market. Some of this would have been reinsured internationally.

Comment by David Todd: While this insurance loss is not exceptional, it comes at a difficult time for the space insurance market. Combined with actual and expectedin-orbit claims already likely to total more than US$400 million for this year, losses are now likely to easily outweigh received premiums on a calendar year basis. This is despite an initial rise in premium rates, following the net market loss from last year, which in most cases had yet to come through. Premiums are now likely to be depressed because of launch delays caused by the coronavirus outbreak. With so many launches delayed, China had become virtually “the only game in town”. But after this launch setback, combined with last month’s Long March 7A failure, China is likely to delay further launches until it is sure that its quality control is satisfactory.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

China’s CGWIC wins turnkey order for Palapa N1 comsat and non-binding order for PSN-7

Space News (Caleb Henry) reports that the China Great Wall Industries Corp has had another success with its strategy of offering Read more

China launches fourth secretive communications technology test satellite

Lifting-off at 1521 GMT, on 17 October, a Long March-3B/G2 rocket has dropped-off the TJSW-4 satellite into a Geostationary Transfer Read more

Long March 3B launches Beidou satellite on way to highly inclined geosynchronous orbit

China launched another satellite as part of its Beidou navigation satellite constellation at 1441 GMT on 20 April 2019.  The Read more

Late News: China launches its Tianlian 2-01 relay sat on Long March 3B

China has launched the latest version of its Tianlian data relay satellites which are broadly equivalent to NASA's TDRS types.  Read more

Long March 3B puts Chinasat 6C into orbit

A Long March 3B-G2 (CZ-3B-G2) rocket successfully put into orbit the Chinasat 6C (Zhongxing 6C) communications satellite into a supersynchronous Read more

China launches first Algerian GEO comms satellite

Lifting off from the Xichang Satellite Launch Center, China, a Long March 3B-G2 (CZ 3B-G2), medium lift rocket has carried Read more

Chinasat 9A recovers itself after launch stranding – but loss of lifespan will mean an insurance loss

The CHINASAT 9A Direct-To-Home (DTH) broadcast satellite reportedly managed to recover itself into the geostationary Earth orbit (GEO) belt by 5 Read more

Long March 3B puts Chinasat 9A into wrong orbit resulting in likely US$129 million insurance loss (Updated)

An under-performing third-stage of a Long March 3B-G2 rocket has left the Chinasat 9A Direct-To-Home (DTH) broadcast satellite in an Read more