Analysis: Putin fires Komarov as head of Roscosmos and puts in Rogozin instead…but Proton Medium survives for now (Corrected)

by | May 24, 2018 | Russia, Seradata News

After three and half years in the job, the mild-mannered technocrat Igor Komarov has been given his marching orders by Russian President Vladimir Putin from his position as head of Roscosmos. The reason for Komarov’s departure has not been disclosed. Replacing him is former deputy prime minister, Dmitry Rogozin, a harder-edged Putin loyalist with a Trump-like reputation for rubbishing his (and Putin’s) opponents at home and abroad.

As the new Director General, Rogozin will be in charge of Russia’s space programme as most of Russia’s space companies are controlled by Roscosmos. His appointment could make dealing with Roscosmos and its subsidiaries very difficult since he was put on US and EU sanctions lists after Russia’s annexation of Crimea. It will be interesting to see if Rogozin will even be able to attend the Heads of Space Agencies meeting at the International Astronautical Congress in Bremen, Germany, in October.

President of Russian, Vladimir Putin, appoints Dmitry Rogozin as head of Roscosmos. Courtesy: Roscosmos

Rogozin will have his work cut out on other issues as well.  Russia has been looking over its shoulder at new reusable and heavy-lift launch vehicle technology in the West, and at the rapid advances made by space upstart nations such as China and India. Meanwhile, its faltering economy meant that Roscosmos was starved of the roubles needed to finance a major expansion of its once proud space effort.

This may change with the recent oil price rise, which gives the oil-exporting economy a chance to recover. Russia’s space programme may be a beneficiary of this, but it remains reliant on old designs and technology. A large investment is needed to get new designs operational as fast as possible. Even the “new” Angara rocket family, which has had a protracted development, has yet to reach full operational status, while the overbudget and much delayed Vostochny Cosmodrome in Far Eastern Russia where Angara will mainly operate from has yet to be completed.

In the meantime, some clever make-do-and-mend ingenuity has just about kept Russia’s space programme in the fight. One example is Khrunichev’s stage-cutting modification to the Proton rocket, which made the expendable Proton Medium competitive against SpaceX’s part-reusable Falcon 9 – even if a de facto US prohibition on US space hardware flying on it after 2023 (it is actually a ban on US military use of commercial satellites flown by Russian rockets after that date) may make it commercially unusable.

The fact remains, however, that the Russian space effort is a shadow of its former self with obsolete launch vehicles and satellites, an ageing workforce, a reputation for poor reliability and quality control, financial scandal, inefficiency, bureaucracy and mismanagement and – worst of all – a lack of sufficient funding.

Until all that changes, replacing the head of Roscosmos will probably have no effect at all

Update on 2 June 2018: On 24 May Interfax reported that the Proton Medium (Proton-L) programme was being cancelled “for economic reasons”.  International Launch Services (ILS) – the launch marketing arm of Khrunichev, has formally denied this report. Karen Soriano of ILS states: “The Proton Medium has not been cancelled. Quite the contrary, the program is the highest priority at Khrunichev and the development program continues on schedule.  We look forward to serving our first customer for Proton Medium, Eutelsat.  Future launches on Proton Medium will be announced this month.”

Comment by David Todd: Thankfully this shining light of needs-must creativity and resourcefulness in the Russian space programme now looks to set to survive – at least for now. The Proton Medium (aka Proton L) rocket, which achieves its cost-effectiveness by eliminating the standard Proton M’s third stage and having a lengthened second stage instead, has been attracting interest. As Karen Soriano notes, the international satellite operator Eutelsat has placed a launch booking on the new rocket, with other clients about to be announced.  Nevertheless, whether Proton Medium can continue after 2023 remains to be seen.

 

 

 

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Russia launches third Tundra next-generation Early-warning satellite

The second Soyuz rocket to launch in under 24 hours lifted-off from the Plesetsk Cosmodrome, Russia, at 0746 GMT, 26 Read more

Final Soyuz-FG rocket lifts Soyuz MS-15 mission to the ISS carrying the first Emirati astronaut into orbit

At 1357 GMT on 25 September, a Soyuz-FG rocket lifted off from Launch Site No. 1/5 at the Baikonur Cosmodrome, Read more

Russia launches Progress cargo craft to resupply the ISS

At 1211 GMT on 31 July 2019, a Russian Soyuz 2-1A rocket lifted-off carrying the PROGRESS MS-12 cargo freighter to Read more

IAC 2018 Bremen: Cooperation and inclusiveness were the themes but Russian agency head was rather obviously missing

The 69th International Astronautical Congress (IAC 2018) was held in the city of Bremen near the coast of Northern Germany. The Read more

Putin publicly commits to Russian Heavy Lift launch vehicle and improving Russian space equipment quality

In a recent televised public forum that allows the Russian public to question Russian President Vladimir Putin (albeit that only certain Read more

Analysis: Russian cosmonauts test out FIFA World Cup Match ball in orbit…but who will actually win? Toddy’s Tip(s) here

In a bit of a public relations offensive by Russia (thankfully no chemical warfare is involved in this campaign) the Russian Read more

Analysis: Souring Russo-UK relations may mean that Tim Peake has to fly to ISS on another ship

The likely life-changing effects of the allegedly Russian-produced Novichok nerve-poison assassination attempt on Russian double agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia, and Read more

Soyuz MS-06 craft carrying one cosmonaut and two astronauts returns to Earth

Following the detachment of the Soyuz MS-06 spacecraft from the ISS (International Space Station), at 2308 GMT on 27 February, the Read more

Cookies & Privacy

Click here to read about use of cookies on the website

Categories

Archives