Has ESA’s Tomorrow’s Bird flown the coop?

by | Feb 4, 2009 | ESA, Satellites, Technology | 0 comments

ariane 5 launch 2008.jpg

credit ESA / caption: an Arianespace Ariane 5 launches the Superbird-7 and AMC-21 satellites

Why is the Tomorrow’s Bird study report so delayed? Is it because its conclusions won’t support other European hopes for spaceflight that require a more powerful version of the EADS Astrium Ariane 5?

Tomorrow’s Bird was, is, an 15-month European Space Agency study into what the future satellites, payloads for rockets, will be like in the 2015 to 2025 timeframe that started in 2006. The study was to contribute to decisons regarding a future European launcher that could replace the Ariane 5 and in parallel a prime contractor called Next Generation Launcher was set up to oversee development of a new rocket

But almost five months after I was told that the study would be completed there is still a stoney silence from a normally talkative European Space AgencyI took a lot of interest in Tomorrow’s bird because despite the rocket bias of Flight’s coverage we recognise that the trucks that we write about are really only a link in  the chain to place a capability in orbit that has societal benefits

And because those birds do have a big impact on those trucks. Would we have a Boeing/ULA Delta IV and EADS Astrium/Arianespace Ariane 5 if unmanned spacecraft technology had miniaturised as dramatically as consumer electronics?

And this I think is at the heart of the challenge for ESA and other space agencies. What do you do when your cultural and political push is towards human exploration but cash-strapped government priorities are Earth focused services and the enabling technology for those is pushing spacecraft in a different direction

With the likes of DARPA working on formations of satellites that deliver the same capabilities as today’s large spacecraft it becomes clear that one trend for the orbital infrastructure of tomorrow is many small vehicles. ESA has even decided to study a “super constellation” where many spacecraft cooperate to delievr not one capability such as Earth observation but a range of them including navigation and telecoms

Now you could argue that large rockets can launch multiple such small spacecraft, placing entire formations into orbit, or part of a super constellation into one orbital plane but others might point out the lower cost of multiple ELV Vegas or SpaceX Falcon 1s

I think it is a debate that will develop over the next ten years as space faring nations have to make tough decisions about replacing aging rocket designs while satellite platform and payload technology delivers more per kilo

The likes of spacecraft and launcher builder EADS Astrium, whose delay in finishing its work is said to the reason behind Tomorrow’s Bird late arrival, may not like the conclusions it is drawing

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

NASA to investigate VASIMR propelled lunar tug concept

NASA is to investigate a VASIMIR propelled lunar tug concept according to a procurement synopsis it published last week

French govt study backs Orion Ariane 5 launch

NASA's Orion crew exploration vehicle could be launched by the latest version of Europe's Ariane 5 rocket by 2019 according Read more

Hearing charter gives more human rating study info

The US House of Representatives' committee on science and technology subcommittee on space and aeronautics' hearing charter gave the following Read more

Cancelled NASA Human Rating study had $1 million budget

If starting and then stopping, within a week, a procurement process for human rating commercial crew transport vehicles seems strange Read more

NASA: Ares V cargo launch vehicle contracts imminent

NASA's Ares V cargo launch vehicle design support contracts were supposed to be awarded in the first week of April. Read more

ESA space tourism environmental impact study goes on

In June 2008 Flight reported that the European Space Agency had concluded, after some preliminary data, that suborbital passengers have Read more

Altair: The Lunar Hopper?

For those of you able to make it all the way through the 3h webcast video of the September lunar Read more

Starchaser’s €150,000 European Space Agency report online

UK rocket developer Starchaser Industries has a link on its website to the executive summary of the report it produced Read more

Cookies & Privacy

Click here to read about use of cookies on the website