NTSB finds that pilot error was to blame for SpaceShipTwo failure but so was poor design and training

by | Jul 28, 2015 | Commercial human spaceflight, Personal spaceflight, Space tourism, Suborbital, Technology, Virgin Galactic | 0 comments

The premature in-flight deployment of the feathered tail plane speed braking system was the primary cause of the destruction of the Virgin Galactic SpaceShipTwo (VSS Enterprise) on 31 October 2015, the formal investigation into the accident has concluded. The US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) investigation found that the co-pilot aboard, Michael Alsbury, pulled a lever to unlock the wing/tail-planes at the wrong point in the flight. The accident report noted that he was in a high workload situation at the time with accelerations/vibrations being experienced.

The wing should have come out in a controlled manner at the unpowered highpoint of the flight and at a velocity of Mach 1.4, as commanded to do so under electric motor power triggered by another set of levers. Instead the premature unlocking combined with transonic aerodynamic loads to cause the wing to come out at Mach 0.92 during the rocket-powered ascent. This caused the craft to pitch at 9g, breaking the craft apart.

The NTSB declared that that SpaceShipTwo’s manufacturer, Scaled Composites, had had a “failure to consider and protect against the possibility that a single human error could result in a catastrophic hazard”.  For example, an inhibitor system could have been introduced to prevent the wing unlocking before the correct Mach number was achieved.  This inhibitor system has, subsequent to the accident, been integrated into the SpaceShipTwo design by Scaled Composites.

This was not the only measure that could have prevented the tragedy, which killed Alsbury and seriously injured the pilot, Peter Siebold (Siebold managed to eject from the smashed up craft). The NTSB also criticised the lack of training and instruction in the rocket plane’s handbook to reinforce the pilots’ understanding of the hazard of premature unlocking of the wing.

Finally, the Federal Aviation Authority’s Office of Commercial Space Transportation also came under fire from the investigators for being too quick, admittedly while under political and managerial pressure, to pass the rocket plane for flight despite not properly examining all the safety issues, especially related to human factors.  The NTSB noted that there was a lack of expertise in the Office of Commercial Space Transportation on human-factor issues related to accidents.

BBC News televised image of photograph showing SpaceShipTwo's destruction. Courtesy: BBC

BBC News televised image of photograph showing SpaceShipTwo’s destruction. Courtesy: BBC

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Analysis: Branson realises space dream as he flies to the ‘edge of space’

Virgin Galactic founder Sir Richard Branson fulfilled a boyhood dream when he flew as ‘Astronaut 001” on his company’s SpaceShipTwo Read more

Branson & Bezos race to space

Virgin Galactic announced at the beginning of July that its founder Richard Branson will be a passenger on the next Read more

Suborbital ventures on the threshold to space

Blue Origin founder Jeff Bezos is to fly on the first crewed mission of the New Shepard, which is scheduled Read more

Virgin Galactic completes a SpaceShipTwo suborbital test flight

At 1526 GMT on 22 May Virgin Galactic achieved its first successful suborbital crewed mission from Spaceport America, New Mexico. Read more

Was it an abort or launch failure? SpaceShipTwo abandons launch one second after ignition

Virgin Galactic’s SpaceShipTwo Unity rocket plane was air-dropped on a suborbital test flight from its mother ship WhiteKnightTwo Eve (which Read more

Virgin Atlantic woes leads Sir Richard Branson to sell part of Virgin Group’s stake in Virgin Galactic

With the UK Government about to impose a 14-day quarantine on arriving passengers from most other countries, UK airlines and Read more

Virgin Galactic merger with SCH is heralded by jump in share price (Updated)

In a vote on 23 October, shareholders of SCH (Social Capital Hedosophia Holdings Corp.) approved its merger with upcoming space Read more

Virgin Galactic to merge with already publicly traded Social Capital Hedosophia in US$1.3bn deal

Space tourism operator Virgin Galactic (VG) and the investment partnership, Social Capital Hedosophia (SCH) announced on 8 July that they Read more

Cookies & Privacy

Click here to read about use of cookies on the website