US Senators plead with Biden for more money for NASA human lunar lander

by | Feb 4, 2021 | Apollo, Blue Origin, exploration, NASA, Seradata News

With just over one quarter of the funding it needed from Congress (US$850 million versus the US$3.2 billion requested) for its Human Landing System (HLS) – a lunar lander for its Artemis programme –  NASA has been forced to delay the programme.  The three contractors  Blue Origin, Dynetics and SpaceX, were to have been whittled down two for their designs to go forward in February. These have been formally told that the award date has now been delayed until 30 April.  The three contractors have already received funding for initial design work: Blue Origin US$579 million, Dynetics US$253 million, SpaceX US$135 million.

With more than a hint of warning that China might beat USA back to the Moon 11 Senators from the Democrat side have urged the Biden Administion via a public letter to properly fund the programme.

“NASA’s Artemis Program will return America to deep space, support economic recovery, strengthen national security, promote scientific research, and inspire the next generation. The HLS Program will develop 21st century crewed lunar landers – a critical piece of the Artemis architecture. We urge you to proceed with the planned selection and to include all necessary funding for HLS in your FY 2022 budget request.” said the senators in the letter.

Illustration showing Blue Moon lander with notional ascent vehicle. Courtesy: Blue Origin

Even if this funding is realised, it is generally accepted within the space industry that the Trump Administration’s target date for a human lunar return landing of 2024 could not have been met.  Because of the relative “weakness” of the European ATV-derived Orion service module which limits the craft to high lunar orbits, any human lander will need both a transfer stage and hard-to-store high energy cryogenic propellants.  Apart from the funding shortfall, the need to develop technologies for the cold storage and transfer of these prone-to-boil-off propellants is the main technical reason why the HLS programme is likely to be delayed – probably back to the originally conceived 2028.  Apollo’s lunar lander used during 1969-72 employed admittedly much less energetically efficient, but much easier to store, hypergolic propellant combination.

Aptly, given his name, the HLS lunar lander’s fate may be influenced by Biden’s newly appointed chief science adviser, Eric Lander.  Biden’s decision to display a sample of lunar rock brought back from the Apollo 17 mission in his Oval Office did give notice that Biden was interested in space exploration.

Update on 10 February 2021: Since this piece was written, the SLS launch system’s main political supporter in the US Senate, Senator Richard Shelby, has announced that he will not be running for re-election as a Senator in 2022.  Meanwhile, the White House has reaffirmed its commitment to the Artemis project, albeit not committing to a date for a human return to the Moon.



About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

NASA chooses SpaceX Starship derivative for human lunar lander but was the choice forced by limited funding?

While Elon Musk previously hinted at it on his Twitter feed, NASA formally announced on 26 April that it had Read more

SpaceX Falcon Heavy selected to launch Astrobotic Griffin lunar lander in 2023

Astrobotic has selected SpaceX's Falcon Heavy rocket to fly its first GRIFFIN lunar lander to the Moon. This is the Read more

SpaceX carries out fourth Starlink mission of March and orbits 60 more satellites

At 0828 GMT on 24 March SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 vehicle carrying 60 STARLINK satellites from Cape Canaveral Read more

Third Starlink launch in March puts another 60 sats into orbit and sets new rocket re-use record

At 1001 GMT on 14 March a SpaceX Falcon 9 launched from Kennedy Space Centre, Florida carrying 60 STARLINK satellites. Read more

US Space Force hands out four launch contracts: two apiece to ULA and SpaceX

On 9 March 2021 the US Space Force (USSF) awarded launch contracts for four upcoming missions planned to launch in Read more

Following a long series of delays SpaceX has managed to launch its lingering Starlink mission

On 4 March 2021 at 0824 GMT SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 vehicle from the Kennedy Space Center, Florida, Read more

Not quite “Third time’s a charm” for SpaceX Spaceship prototype SN10 as it lands successfully but later explodes…and then SN11 falls out of the sky (Updated)

After two explosive landing failures with the SpaceX Starship prototypes SN8 and SN9, SpaceX engineer and commentator John Inspruker tempted Read more

SpaceX successfully launches another Starlink batch but loses the first-stage during landing attempt (Updated)

Lifting off from Cape Canaveral, Florida, at 0359 GMT on 16 February, a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket carried the second Read more

Cookies & Privacy

Click here to read about use of cookies on the website