IAC 2018 Bremen: SLS future is assured for now as ICPS “tweak” improvements are planned alongside EUS upgrades

by | Oct 15, 2018 | Launches, NASA, SLS, Technology

While the SLS Block I variant is nearly certain to achieve flight status, new heavy-lift rockets on the block threaten to usurp later variants of this huge US$20 billion Heavy Lift launch vehicle (HLV). Nevertheless, during the Heads of Agencies’ press conference, NASA’s new administrator, Jim Bridenstine, was adamant in declaring that SLS and the Orion human-carrying spacecraft would survive the onset of new commercial HLVs and suggested that the SLS would work in cooperation with them.

Commercial launches are be part of NASA’s Lunar Gateway construction plan. Courtesy: Seradata/David Todd

In fact, NASA’s Lunar Gateway construction plans specifically include “commercial launches” in its schedule, as shown in the paper presented by NASA’s Jason Crusan (IAC-18.A5.1.1).

After some setbacks, the SLS programme is back on track. Steve Creech, SLS Strategic Development Manager, revealed that the main LOx (liquid oxygen) tank for the 26 metric ton, TLI capable SLS Block I would be ready early next year, while the liquid hydrogen tank would be ready by the autumn.

With respect to other choke points on the critical path in the SLS/Orion schedule, Nico Dettman, head of the exploration group at ESA, said some design changes would be made to the service module between the unmanned Orion EM-1 mission, currently planned for 2020-21, and the crewed EM-2 mission in 2022. He noted however that the former flight would be more forgiving in its requirements given its uncrewed status.

Oliver Juckenhofel, head of on-orbit services and exploration at Airbus DS, said t would include mass reduction measures and some new upgraded electronic components. He suggested that the new X-wing solar array configuration had a few advantages over the “Mickey Mouse” designs originally envisaged by Lockheed Martin, mainly that the stress-reducing flexible joints would allow them to bend backwards during manoeuvres.

The lift capabilities of SLS variants as planned. Courtesy: NASA


With respect to later versions of the SLS, NASA has just reopened negotiations with Boeing to optimise the design of the EUS to further extend the 34-36 metric ton TLI (Trans Lunar Injection) capabilities of the now delayed SLS Block IB. This will not now fly until the fourth SLS mission at the earliest. The final and most powerful SLS Block II version, which able to carry 150 metric tons to LEO using the EUS as well as new advanced boosters, will not now be needed until the 2030s.

The late arrival of the EUS resulted in the SLS having to fly in a Block I configuration using its Delta IV rocket derived Interim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage (ICPS) for both the first and second SLS flights, the latter of which is the first human carrying EM-2 mission meaning that the SLS Block I has had to be human-rated after all.

The third SLS Block I flight after EM-1 and EM-2 will be an unmanned “cargo” mission as it is due to launch the scientific probe, the Europa Clipper, in 2022 at the earliest.  This science mission to Jupiter’s icy moon, very much benefits from the power of the SLS in allowing it a more direct flight trajectory, thus saving years in flight time.

While the ICPS could be stretched further, according to NASA’s ICPS specialist Dr Kimberley F. Robinson, NASA is currently planning to make just “performance tweaks” to it. These will add a metric ton or two to its lifting performance which will benefit the Europa Clipper mission’s flexibility. Presenting the IAC-18.D2.9-A5.4.1 paper in lieu of Steve Creech, Robinson said that these minor improvements could be done without having to recertify the stage, whereas a full propellant tank stretch would definitely need this.

Comment by David Todd:  While the future of the Block I version of the SLS is assured (at least for the three or possibly four flights for which it has already has RS-25D engines), the same cannot be said for the SLS Block IB. By delaying the EUS upper stage, NASA and its Boeing partners can give the SLS Block IB slightly more payload via an EUS redesign which would be useful for the construction of the Lunar Gateway. However, this move also allows a much easier cancellation of the EUS and SLS Block IB version (and later SLS Block II) should NASA wish to do so. This might happen if commercial heavy lifters such as the Blue Origin New Armstrong and the SpaceX BFR show that they are likely to work.

By the way, one alternative to the SLS Block IB with its EUS would be to further upgrade the SLS Block I. During the early design studies of the SLS, analyses of different engine and configuration options for the upper stage showed that one possibility would be to stretch the tanks of SLS Block I’s ICPS. This would get it close to the 34-37 metric ton TLI performance of the EUS equipped SLS Block IB.

The days of the later SLS Block IB and Block II variants could, therefore, be numbered and they may remain as just “paper designs”. Nevertheless, for the time being, the SLS Block 1B remains integral to the Lunar Gateway plan.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

SpaceX Falcon 9 launches Starlink Group 5-2

On 26 January 2023, at 0932 GMT, a Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 successfully launched 56 Starlink Gen2 satellites from Space Read more

Japan completes its first launch of the year of the radar reconnaissance satellite IGS RADAR-7

Kicking off its launch year, Japan has placed a radar reconnaissance satellite into near-500 km sun-synchronous low Earth orbit (LEO). Read more

NASA goes Nuclear-Thermal as it plans to launch engine on DARPA’s DRACO project’s X-NTRV technology test mission in 2027

Nuclear Thermal rocket propulsion has been mooted since the 1960s. The idea is to use nuclear power to heat rocket Read more

Rocket Lab’s Electron KS rocket performs another successful launch – this time from the US East Coast

After another day's delay due to bad weather, a Rocket Lab Electron KS rocket successfully launched three 30 kg Hawk Read more

First ISS spacewalk for 2023 completed

On 20 January 2023 JAXA astronaut Koichi Wakata and NASA astronaut Nicole Mann opened the Quest airlock hatch at 1312 Read more

SpaceX Falcon 9 launches Starlink Group 2-4 from Vandenberg

At 1543 GMT on 19 January a SpaceX Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 rocket conducted its first Starlink mission of 2023. Read more

SpaceX deploys GPS satellite for US Space Force

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 from Cape Canaveral, USA at 1224 GMT on 18 January.  The vehicle Read more