NASA paints a brave face on SLS engine test failure (Updated)

by | Jan 18, 2021 | exploration, NASA, Seradata News, Technology

NASA might have said that it wanted a minimum of 250 seconds’ worth of engine firing plus gimbal movements to attain whether the SLS core stage was safe to launch, but it did not get it at the test firing at the Stennis Space Center, Mississippi, USA. In the end, the test firing at 1030 GMT on 16 January,  lasted just 67 seconds. This test was to evaluate the four RS-25 former Space Shuttle Main Engines (SSME) – since refurbished and fitted with new computer controllers – that power the SLS core stage.

An automatic shutdown was caused by Engine No 2’s  hydraulic generating Core Stage Auxiliary Power Units (CAPUs) exceeding pre-set limits related to the actual test stand being used. The CAPUs provide hydraulic pressure to the engine’s two Thrust Vector Control actuators. The result was that once these limits were exceeded, the computerised system ordered the faulty CAPU to shut down and with it all four RS-25 engines.  NASA pointed out that on a real flight, that any CAPU failure would have resulted in the remaining CAPUs making up for the lost CAPU’s hydraulic failure and that an all engine shutdown would not have been ordered.  Nevertheless, while it has been mooted that enough engine firing data was produced by the test, it is likely that another test will be required before the SLS stage is cleared. This could even delay is first unmanned flight until next year.

NASA’s well regarded outgoing Administrator Jim Bridenstine, who must have wished for a better send off, accepted that the final “Green Run” programme test had not gone to plan. Nevertheless he put a brave face on the situation with the suggestion a maiden flight for SLS this year may still be possible. “They’re still looking through the data, but based on the preliminary feedback, I’m actually feeling good about it,” said Bridenstine.

RS-25D/E on display at IAC 2019. Courtesy: Seradata (David Todd)

SLS is facing a difficult future. Already late and overbudget, and now apparently further delayed, it now faces the challenge of the imminent arrival of the more capable, and very much cheaper-to-operate, SpaceX heavy lift rocket Starship/Superbooster combination.

Computer image of SLS Block 1. Courtesy: NASA

Many are already wondering if NASA would be wise to pursue the more powerful Block 1B and Block 2 versions of the SLS via the upgrade of the four RL-10 engine Exploration Upper Stage at all. The EUS has recently been given the technical green light and been given the budget funding to be proceeded with. Critics point out that a possible alternative to allow Project Artemis lunar landings would be to use a beefed up SpaceX super heavy to carry a lunar landing craft to lunar orbit, and just use the imminent SLS Block 1 (which uses the current ICPS upper stage) only as an Orion carrying launch vehicle.

SLS has already lost some of its key support in the US Senate. While it could be said that Senators were its fathers as they insisted that former Space Shuttle technology should be used on SLS, this “pork barrel” political support is waning. For example, Republican Senator Richard Shelby, a strong supporter of SLS given that much of the work is done in his Alabama constituency, will now no longer be Chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee – the main decider of NASA’s budget including those for individual NASA programmes.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

SLS Wet Dress Rehearsal is dogged by delays which eventually postpones it

The much delayed SLS Heavy-lift Launch Vehicle (HLV) due to take NASA astronauts back to the Moon won’t be going Read more

SLS saves itself with successful full-duration engine firing but its career may still be short

NASA’s much delayed and very expensive SLS heavy-lift launch vehicle (HLV) has coming under renewed criticism as SpaceX’s partly reusable Read more

Despite anti-democratic attempt to storm its government, the USA gets a new President – with Senate power which is bad news for SLS

After politically traumatic events in Washington DC, the inauguration of President elect Joe Biden and his Vice President elect Kamala Read more

Bridenstine notes public-private partnerships in NASA push to develop crewed lunar landers

At the 35th Space Symposium in Colorado on 9 April, NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine put some meat on the bare Read more

Pence commits NASA to human return to the Moon before 2024 as it goes cold on further development of SLS

The Trump Administration has signalled a change of space policy on a human return to the Moon. Addressing the National Space Read more

Analysis: In the Great Space Race China retakes lead for human lunar return but USA is still favourite for Mars

While the original space race between superpowers - the USA and Soviet Union during the 1960s - was effectively ended Read more

NASA budget: WFIRST mission is cancelled while ISS time is marked – but SLS is thrown a lifeline

NASA’s acting administrator, Robert Lightfoot, revealed in a speech at NASA Marshall Spaceflight Center at Huntsville, Alabama, that NASA’s budget had received Read more

Elon Musk repositions SpaceX’s Mars transportation system as “Jack of all Trades” while Lockheed Martin fills its Mars excursion gap

SpaceX leader Elon Musk has explained how his vision for travel to Mars encompasses uses in low Earth orbit and Read more