NASA rethink: SLS Block 1 is likely to fly humans after all…as China’s space programme plans its own “Taikonaut” lunar landings

by | Apr 26, 2018 | China, exploration, NASA, Seradata News, SLS

After US Congress decided to cancel the human-rating of the Delta IV upper-stage-derived ICPS (Interim Cryogenic Propulsion System) it looked as though the SLS Block 1 rocket (itself delayed until 2020) would only ever fly once on an unmanned flight called EM-1 (Exploration Mission 1).  The idea was that all human flights starting from EM-2 onwards would be on the SLS Block 1B using a new more powerful Exploration Upper Stage (EUS) – but not until 2023 at the earliest.  However this plan now looks likely to be changed.

Faced with a prospect of development delays to the EUS (especially with its software), and with critics pointing out that later Block 1B and Block 2 versions of SLS may soon be redundant given the rapid development of much cheaper-to-fly commercial heavy lift launch vehicles (HLVs) such as the SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy and BFR and Blue Origin’s New Glenn and New Armstrong, NASA has come to the conclusion that it needs to get the SLS flying astronauts sooner rather than later.

Computer image of SLS Block 1. Courtesy: NASA

Bill Gerstenmaier, NASA’s human future exploration supremo, has reportedly said that the Exploration Mission 2 (EM-2) – the first human flight on the Orion spacecraft –  could now be on an ICPS equipped SLS Block 1 – and by implication, flown much earlier than 2023.  Gerstenmaier notes that the ICPS was not as expensive to human-rate as first thought.

Comment by David Todd: This is a start. But what is really needed is a decision to use the SLS Block 1 for early human sortie exploration flights along with suitably developed Lunar Surface Access Module (LSAM). This publication has been pressing for this for a long time.  This could be done, and there appears to be political pressure for such an early lunar return mission building in the White House.  At the very least sortie missions such as these would someway justify the US$18 billion spent on SLS/Orion. SLS would thus find niche as an interim exploration HLV, while also being a back up “insurance” should commercial HLVs falter.

In the meantime, US Congress has voted to give NASA an extra US$350 million to build a second Mobile Launch Platform (MLP) which could allow such a dual SLS launch mission to take place.  An initial SLS Block 1 would launch a lander (in unmanned condition) first, followed shortly afterwards by the second launch carrying the astronauts to the Moon in an Orion. These two spacecraft would  then rendezvous and dock with each other in lunar orbit followed by a landing of astronauts in the LSAM.  This would be followed by an ascent to lunar orbit, a redocking, and a return to Earth by Orion.

Post Script:  In spite of the recommendation above, NASA’s current plan is to build a lunar orbiting exploration outpost space station well before any landing attempts on the Moon take place in the late 2020s – some 60 years after the original Apollo landings.  As such, it could well be a Chinese flag sown into the space suit of a Chinese moonwalking astronaut “Taikonaut” which is on the lunar surface first.  China’s space programme is apparently considering faster less complicated Apollo-class human lunar surface exploration missions like those suggested in the comment section above. At a space conference in Harbin, China, in April,  Zhou Jianping, chief designer of China’s manned space programme, has declared that China has the technology to do this.  China’s manned space programme has recently asked its general population for design ideas for lunar landing and ascent modules.

Meanwhile, China’s overall space programme controlling body and its equivalent of NASA, the Chinese National Space Administration, has also laid out a plan for an eventual Chinese base on the Moon consisting of a series of interconnected habitation modules for its astronauts.  This “lunar palace” would be used to advance technologies for an eventual Chinese human Mars landing mission.  Such a mission might even be launched from this lunar base.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

SLS saves itself with successful full-duration engine firing but its career may still be short

NASA’s much delayed and very expensive SLS heavy-lift launch vehicle (HLV) has coming under renewed criticism as SpaceX’s partly reusable Read more

IAC 2018 Bremen: SLS future is assured for now as ICPS “tweak” improvements are planned alongside EUS upgrades

While the SLS Block I variant is nearly certain to achieve flight status, new heavy-lift rockets on the block threaten Read more

Todd May – the well-regarded “midwife” of SLS – is to retire from NASA

Napoleon once said that he did not care if his generals were any good, but rather, whether they were lucky. Read more

Bookmaker was right: Orion will be next US crewed capsule if first SLS launch carries humans…and Musk does not do it first

A couple of years ago a UK/Irish bookmaker (Paddy Power) was offering odds on which US spacecraft would carry the next humans Read more

Opinion: Was NASA’s US$18 billion development of SLS a waste of time and money?

With Elon Musk, of SpaceX, about to announce his master plan to send mankind to Mars (using a massive Super Heavy-lift Launch Vehicle) and with unmanned Read more

SLS is big winner as NASA gets funding rise above expectations

NASA’s budget has been increased to US$19.285 billion, some US$756 million more than requested. The bulk of the extra money has Read more

World Launcher Review is necessary reading for anyone wishing to launch a spacecraft

The World Launcher Review has technical descriptions and commentaries covering every major orbital launch vehicle flying and in development, including their launch sites and Read more

Categories

Archives

Tags