Not quite “Third time’s a charm” for SpaceX Spaceship prototype SN10 as it lands successfully but later explodes…and then SN11 falls out of the sky (Updated)

by | Mar 4, 2021 | Launches, Reliability Info, Seradata News, SpaceX

After two explosive landing failures with the SpaceX Starship prototypes SN8 and SN9, SpaceX engineer and commentator John Inspruker tempted fate again on 3 February for the SN10 test flight by saying “Third time’s a charm.”

SN10 ascends to 10km before its successful landing (even if it did later explode). Courtesy: SpaceX

At this point it was true that the SN10 test flight had achieved the object of its test flight: a high-altitude launch followed by a successful landing at its Boca Chica base in Texas. But several minutes after the landing disaster struck when the craft exploded.

The initial abort happened after a first ignition attempt failed. Minutes later, ignition was achieved and the test flight was successfully made to a planned altitude of 10km. The already perfected technique of a flat pancake orientated descent was then made to slow the Starship craft down. A last-minute pitch up to an engine down configuration also worked well.

This time there was no engine failure to prevent a slow touch down. And instead of just two, all three raptor engines were initially ignited. This increased the chance of having at least one working engine for the landing as during the fast-paced approach there would be little time to attempt an engine reignition.

The troubles started before the landing when an apparent loss of thrust in the braking engine caused a faster than planned touch down. This loss of thrust was later attributed to partial helium ingestion from the fuel header tank with bubbles causing a loss of thrust. The helium was added to keep propellant pressurisation of the propellants ahead of the landing, especially during the horizontal descent. The resulting crunching landing caused two of the Starship’s six deployed landing legs to collapse as well apart of the rocket stage’s skirt.

The partial leg collapse caused the safely landed Starship stage to start leaning over. It also had a fire burning beneath from an apparent propellant spillage. Eight minutes after its landing, the leaning Starship then appeared to have an explosion at its base, which made it jump up from the ground. After this unplanned “relaunch”, the lower structure then exploded with the stage falling back to Earth in flames.

In a news release, SpaceX used Elon Musk’s favourite terminology for an unexpected explosion: “As if the flight test was not exciting enough, SN10 experienced a rapid unscheduled disassembly shortly after landing.”  The cause of the post-landing failure is being investigated. SpaceX is considering allowing the Starship to make the final landing on two engines instead of one in future flights.

The movie clip of the explosion can be seen here: Chris B – NSF on Twitter: “An amazing shot of Starship SN10’s post-landing Rapid Unplanned Disassembly (RUD) after Wednesday’s test flight. ➡️https://t.co/bOsEo1u0u0 https://t.co/FmNtYBFmIe” / Twitter

A still from NASASpaceflight.com’s movie clip of the SN10 post flight explosion. Courtesy: NASASpaceflight.com via Twitter

Update on 31 March 2021:  The follow-on test flight on 30 March, again at Boca Chica, the Starship prototype SN11’s flight was also seen to have ended in failure.  While observation of its launch was very difficult due to it being shrouded in heavy sea fog, its telemetry and on-board cameras showed that the launch to 10 km altitude worked as planned.  However, five minutes 49 seconds into the launch the coverage was cut. This was the point at which the three engines were due to be fired up for the descent.  An explosion is thought to have taken place with the carcass of the rocket stage plus some extra debris was seen to fall out of the sky and impact the ground near the planned landing zone.  As Chief designer and founder of SpaceX, Elon Musk, drily noted: “At least the crater is in the right place!”

Elon Musk later revealed that a “hard start” – a high pressure ignition event/explosion caused by too much propellant in the turbopump – had occurred in one of the three rocket engines. The cause is was due to a fire caused by methane fuel leak on Engine 2 during the ascent phase which “fried” part of avionics and which, in turn, led to the hard start.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned Seradata database. Trusted by over 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, Seradata is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to https://www.seradata.com/product/

Related Articles

Galactic Energy of China suffers first launch failure of its Ceres-1 rocket losing insured Jilin 1 Gaofen 04B-01

Having been launched at 0459 GMT on the morning of 21 September it later filtered out that the Ceres-1 Y11 Read more

Starlink Group 6-17 is launched by Falcon 9

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 rocket from Cape Canaveral, Florida, USA at 0338 GMT on 20 September Read more

Electron KS rocket has another failure losing Acadia 2 radar Earth observation satellite

Rocket Lab launched Electron KS from Māhia Peninsula, New Zealand, at 0655 GMT on 19 September 2023. The Electron was Read more

China launches Long March 2D carrying Yaogan 39 trio

China successfully launched a Long March 2D/2 (CZ-2D/2) from Xichang Satellite Launch Centre, Sichuan Province, China at 0312 GMT on Read more

SpaceX launches Falcon 9 with Starlink Group 6-16 aboard

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 rocket from Cape Canaveral, Florida, USA at 0338 GMT on 16 September Read more

Soyuz MS-24 is launched into orbit on Soyuz 2-1a from Baikonur on way to ISS

Soyuz MS-24 was launched via a Soyuz 2-1a rocket into orbit at 1544 GMT on 15 September 2023 from Baikonur Read more

Victus Nox payload is launched by Firefly Alpha in rapid response launch test

There was an unexpected launch of the Firefly Alpha rocket (its third flight) which took place from Vandenberg, California, at Read more

Film of ancient ‘alien bodies’ is displayed at Congress of Mexico hearing

Following on from similar US Congressional hearings on UFOs which appeared to have footage of flying UFOs, at a Mexican Read more

Chinese Long March 6A rocket carries new Yaogan 40 triplet to LEO

Launching at 0430 GMT on 10 September a Chinese Long March 6A (CZ-6A) rocket carried the Yaogan 40 mission into Read more

Categories

Archives

Tags

nasaspacexecoreviewsissesaArianespacevideochina25virgin galacticfalcon 9ULAFalcon 9v1.2FT Block 5RoscosmosevaDGAspacewalkaviation weekaressoyuzIGTInternational Space StationBeidouawardsspaceBlue OriginSatellite broadcastingRocket LabStarlinkrussiamoonCargo Return VehicleboeingAirbus DSmarsblogresearchISROOneWeborionspaceshiptwojaxaimpacthyperboladelaymarsdemocratrocketEutelsatobamagoogle lunar prizelunarhypertextlaunchVegaSEStourismbarack obamaconstellationfiguresnorthspaceflightthales alenia spacenode 2fundedRaymond LygoIntelsatLockheed Martin2009Express MD-2Atlas Vromess2Elon Muskdassault aviationaviationLucy2008wk2sstlukradiotestmissilesuborbitaldocking portexplorationAriane 5 ECAVirgin OrbitinternetChina Manned Space EngineeringAriane 5SLSsts-1222010flightspace tourismNorthrop Grummancotsnewspapermissile defensegalileospaceportExpress AMU 1Long March 2D/2Electronbuildspace stationaltairLong March 4Cinternational astronautical congresssoyuz 2-1ashuttleProton MEuropean Space AgencyLauncherOneCosmosIntelsat 23scaled compositeshanleybudgetrulesnew yorkAriane 6shenzhouspace shuttleatvVietnamcongressMojaveboldenLong March 2COrbital ATKnew shepardInmarsatGuiana Space CenteriaccnesksclawsSpace Systems/LoralUK Space AgencyLong March 4BILSUS Air Forceprotonlunar landerTalulah RileyApollodarpaFalcon 9v1.2 Block 5Kuaizhou 1AVega CSkylonAstriumeupicturebaseusaastronautdragonlanderfiveeventTelesatSSLElectron KSNorth KoreaAprilSNCWednesdayinterviewSea Launchfalcon50thcustomerlinkLong Marchatlantissuccessor