It was probably a design error what done it said NASA about SpaceX launch failure in 2015

by | Mar 13, 2018 | Launches, Seradata News, SpaceX

NASA’s independent report into the Falcon 9 launch failure, which lost Dragon CRS-7 and eight small Flock/Dove satellites on 28 June 2015, has finally been released. It specifically criticises a SpaceX design error – and by implication its chief designer: Elon Musk. The report has been published as NASA prepares the ground ahead of its safety analysis of Boeing and SpaceX commercial crew systems, which will fly in 2020.

The vehicle exploded 2 minutes 19 seconds after launch, just before first stage shutdown, at an altitude of 45km. An overpressure event was detected in a second-stage oxygen tank less than a second before the explosion. An investigation into the cause of the Falcon 9 (v1.1) launch failure in June came to the conclusion that a strut holding down a helium-filled composite overwrapped pressure vessel (COPV) inside an oxygen tank snapped (probably near the bolt attachment point). The COPV tank either struck the LOx tank dome causing it to rupture, or there was a helium leak, which allowed helium to over-pressurise and blow up the second-stage oxygen tank. The buoyancy of the helium tank actually increases with rocket acceleration.

The subsequent independent investigation by NASA agreed with the above scenarios, but disagreed that the most likely cause was a material defect in the part supplied by the subcontractor. NASA’s investigators argued that it was poor design in the selection of the rod/strut material (an industrial rather than an aerospace grade stainless steel was chosen without adequate analysis given to the loads and cryogenic environment) that was a more likely cause of failure. The launch, spacecraft and the spacecraft’s contents were not insured.

NASA’s independent report into the Falcon 9 failure of 28 June 2015. Courtesy: NASA




About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

UK Ministry of Defence forgets its past loyalties and chooses SpaceX over Arianespace to launch its Skynet 6A comsat

The UK Ministry of Defence has surprised the pan-European launch provider Arianespace by selecting a SpaceX Falcon 9 launch for Read more

SpaceX to launch Earth observation MBZ-SAT for UAE in 2023

The Mohammed Bin Rashid Space Centre (MBRSC), United Arab Emirates (UAE), has selected American launch provider SpaceX to launch its Read more

April marks another Falcon 9 launch of 60 Starlink satellites

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9v1.2 Block 5 vehicle from Cape Canaveral, Florida, USA at 1634 GMT on 7 April Read more

Record breaker! 143 satellites carried by SpaceX Falcon 9 was most ever launched on single rocket

Space and satellite tracking analysts (including those at Seradata) were reeling at their increased workload as a total of 143 Read more

Falcon 9 launches “dog house” looking sea-level monitoring satellite Sentinel 6A Michael Freilich

The Sentinel 6A (Michael Freilich) satellite (aka Jason CS-1) was launched successfully into a Sun-synchronous orbit with its lift-off taking Read more

Falcon 9 launches GPS III-4 navsat for US military (and civilian users)

After a series of launch delays including an engine induced launch abort in October, the GPS III-4 (aka GPS III Read more

SpaceX launches 15th Falcon 9 mission carrying Starlink sats (14th carrying operational ones)

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 vehicle carrying 60 Starlink satellites from Kennedy Space Center, Florida, USA at 1531 GMT Read more

SpaceX posts another successful launch of 60 Starlink satellites using its Falcon 9 rocket including a first stage recovery…but fairing recovery plan has a hole in it

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 vehicle carrying 60 Starlink satellites from the ex-Space Shuttle Pad 39A leased from NASA Read more