SpaceX and Blue Origin plan next reusable steps but ARCA’s single stage expendable may beat them all

by | Apr 12, 2017 | Blue Origin, Seradata News, SpaceX, Technology

While SpaceX concentrates on making its partly reusable rocket even more low cost, by dint of recovering the payload fairing using control thrusters and parachutes, it has even grander ambitions. SpaceX founder Elon Musk has apparently decided to resuscitate his plan to make the second stage of the Falcon 9 rocket series (including the Falcon Heavy) reusable as well as its first stage.

Musk has admitted that the trick is to build such a stage with enough thermal protection and landing equipment to do the job, but which is light enough not to take off too much payload. Musk hints that the first launch of the Falcon 9 Heavy, which is currently payload-less, may be used to fly a trial version on its maiden launch later this year.

Animation still of a reusable Falcon 9 upper stage re-entering Earth’s atmosphere. Courtesy: SpaceX


In the meantime, Jeff Bezos, founder of reusable competitor Blue Origin has let slip that he is considering making the vertically landing New Shepard launch vehicle designed for planned suborbital tourist flights, into a reusable first stage for a small launch vehicle. Such a rocket would use an expendable upper stage and would compete at the other end of the mass spectrum compared to Blue Origin’s planned New Glenn series of reusable launch vehicles.

Of course, European launch provider Arianespace argues strongly that you can make expendables like its planned Ariane 6, competitive enough to compete with reusable rockets, if production line techniques using low cost manufacturing are mastered.

That said, multiple expendable stages means more to build. However, the Romanian ARCA Space Corporation is now planning get round this using its HAAS 2CA. It is an expendable single-stage-to-orbit rocket using some novel technologies to achieve a payload capability of 100kg to LEO.

The rocket uses hydrogen peroxide and kerosene and fires them through a multi-combustion chamber linear aerospike engine (called Executor) with thrust vectoring control via differential throttling to make trajectory changes. Because of its ability to auto adapt to the altitude pressure drop, it promises optimum performance at virtually all flight levels, ARCA claims that this allows the use of up to 30% less fuel than any other rocket engine. The rocket achieves an exceptional mass ratio of 29, the highest ever achieved by an orbital vehicle, by using composite materials in its design. Engineers have long known of the benefits of using such engines, but none have yet been flown. 

Artist’s illustration showing the firing of the HAAS 2CA’s aerospike engine. Courtesy: ARCA

The aim of the HAAS 2CA is to make launches for just US$1 million per flight equating to just US$10,000 per kg of payload.

ARCA Space Corporation secured preliminary partnerships with NASA’s Kennedy, Ames, Wallops, Marshall, Stennis and Johnson Space Centers aiming to increase the flight readiness of the vehicle that is scheduled for the first flight in 2018 from Wallops Flight Facility.

ARCA is a genuine space technology firm, however it does have its detractors, including those who blamed its test regime for the crash of ESA’s ExoMars Schiaparelli lander.

However, if its new HAAS 2CA rocket works then this could put most other small launch vehicles out of business, and could even threaten SpaceX and Blue Origin’s reusable concepts, if it is ever scaled up.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned Seradata database. Trusted by over 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, Seradata is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

Falcon 9 makes two launches on 17 March: for Starlink Group 2-8 and SES-18 and SES-19 respectively…but recently launched Starlink Group 6-1 appears to be sinking

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 from Vandenberg, California, USA at 1926 GMT on 17 March 2023. The vehicle was Read more

Chinese Long March 3B/E launches earth observation satellite into orbit

China successfully launched a Chinese Long March 3B/E rocket carrying the a new geostationary Earth observation satellite, Gaofen-13 02. The Read more

Rocket Lab successfully deploys two Capella Space radar satellites after Electron launch

Rocket Lab successfully launched its Electron rocket and deployed two Capella Space radar imaging satellites into low Earth orbit (LEO). Read more

NASA uses CLPS programme to contract lunar ride for Firefly’s Blue Ghost 2 lunar lander and ESA’s Lunar Pathfinder comms relay spacecraft

Firefly Aerospace has been awarded a second CLPS transportation order to the Moon, this time for the Blue Ghost 2 Read more

SATELLITE 2023: Many different paths towards space sustainability, all it takes is time and money

During the last session of the SATELLITE 2023 conference in Washington DC was the Space Sustainability Services panel. This saw Read more

SATELLITE 2023: Arianespace prefers to look further into the future as 2023 is set to see low number of its launches

At the Launcher Roundtable at SATELLITE 2023 Arianespace CEO, Stéphane Israël, talked about his company's activities for the coming years.  Read more

NASA unveils new spacesuits for Artemis astronauts moon landing

A new style, for a new space era - that's the message NASA wants to send with the unveiling of Read more

With its cash about to run out Virgin Orbit suspends operations and lays off staff

While it has been expected for a while, CNBC broke the story that Virgin Orbit has taken the decision to Read more