Stainless Starhopper test rocket makes static firings and tethered hops as SpaceX destroys large composite tank tooling

by | Apr 8, 2019 | SpaceX, Technology

While it might be sans its “pointy” nose cone after it fell off and was damaged in windy weather, the Starhopper test rocket has nevertheless begun to make static firings and short tethered hops at its Boca Chica test site in Texas. This was announced SpaceX founder and Chief Designer Elon Musk via Twitter.  The rocket is built from stainless steel and acts as the technology test forerunner to the main Starship/Superbooster (formerly known as BFS/BFR) combination.

Starhopper ignites in a static test. Courtesy: SpaceX/YouTube

Choosing stainless steel combined with transpiration cooling has allowed SpaceX to eschew using heavy conventional thermal protection tiles (either ceramic or pica ablative based or combination thereof) for the full sized Starship except for the windward re-entry side of the craft.  Nevertheless, the move was a surprise given that SpaceX itself previously hailed its own success in producing very large very light composite tanks – even though these were very expensive to build and had suffered some testing failures.  As it was, it had been mooted that the Superbooster itself might still have used composite tankage.

However, Musk has further confirmed via Twitter that the main Superbooster rocket element will also use stainless steel as its main structural and skin material, thus helpfully making it able to re-enter from suborbital flight at Mach 8-9 without any extra thermal protection.  Using stainless steel also avoids the problems of composite tanks’ infamously unpredictable failure/delamination mechanisms.

Teslerati.com has reported that SpaceX has now destroyed most of its large scale composite tank tooling.

Comment by David Todd: While using composites as metal tank strengtheners has merit, this writer has long been a detractor of composite-only tanks. The original attempt to use them on the failed X-33 single-stage-to-orbit demonstrator project showed that they were both difficult to make leak proof and that they were prone to unexpected failures.  But while Musk may be embarrassed that he has wasted time and a great deal of money (probably tens of millions of dollars) on the expensive cul-de-sac of large scale composite tank technology, it was no reason for SpaceX to destroy its large size composite tank tooling and hardware for there may be other uses for such large lightweight tanks.

Perhaps this was done as a kind of “Scorched Earth” policy to prevent competitors from benefiting from SpaceX’s manufacturing breakthroughs. Alternatively, it may have been done to convince composite-tank aficionados within SpaceX that there was no way back.

Either way, Musk might argue that as an independent private company it owes nothing to anyone and can do what it likes.

So while we applaud Musk’s wisdom in going for the stainless steel route, nevertheless, the destruction of this composite manufacturing technology was an act of technical vandalism akin to the destruction of the Saturn V’s tooling post Apollo, which might actually hinder human space progress in the longer term.

 

 

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

SpaceX Falcon 9 launches Starlink Group 5-2

On 26 January 2023, at 0932 GMT, a Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 successfully launched 56 Starlink Gen2 satellites from Space Read more

NASA goes Nuclear Thermal as it plans to launch engine on DARPA’s DRACO project test mission in 2027

Nuclear Thermal rocket propulsion has been mooted since the 1960s. The idea is to use nuclear power to heat rocket Read more

SpaceX Falcon 9 launches Starlink Group 2-4 from Vandenberg

At 1543 GMT on 19 January a SpaceX Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 rocket conducted its first Starlink mission of 2023. Read more

SpaceX deploys GPS satellite for US Space Force

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 from Cape Canaveral, USA at 1224 GMT on 18 January.  The vehicle Read more

Falcon Heavy launches USSF-67 two satellite payload on way to GEO with its two boosters landed for future launches (Corrected)

A SpaceX Falcon Heavy Block 5 (px) rocket successfully lifted off from Kennedy Space Center, Florida, USA at 2256 GMT Read more

Events on International Space Station: Dragon CRS-26 departs as do some cubesats

Events on the International Space Station have been more muted after the excitement of the Soyuz MS-22 coolant leak. On Read more

SpaceX Falcon 9 launches batch of 40 OneWeb comsats for competitor

In yet another act of altruism, albeit a revenue earning example, SpaceX used its Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 rocket to Read more

SpaceX Falcon 9 kicks off the new year with launch of Transporter 6 mission

[caption id="attachment_113276" align="alignnone" width="934"] First launch of 2023: the Falcon 0 Transporter-6 rideshare mission. Courtesy: SpaceX[/caption] The sixth Transporter rideshare Read more

Categories

Archives