Seradata
  • Home
  • Products
    • SpaceTrak
  • Conference
    • Seradata Space Conference 2021
    • Previous Conference 2019
  • Resources
    • Launch Market
    • Launch & Space Insurance
    • Satellite Reliability
    • Space Domain Awareness
    • Satellite Market Analysis
    • Satellite Frequencies & Spectrum Analysis
  • About us
    • Our Team
  • Contact us
  • SSI News
  • SpaceTrak Login
Select Page

What a waste of money: Boeing pulls out of DARPA’s XS-1 reusable rocket plane programme forcing its cancellation

by David Todd | Jan 23, 2020 | Launches, Military space, Seradata News, Technology

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Boeing’s engineering credibility was already under fire following the Boeing 737 Max airliner crashes, partial failure of the first unmanned test flight of its commercial crew CST-100 Starliner spacecraft (causing a US$410 million hit to Q4 earnings) and various botched military programmes. But another woe has befallen it. Boeing has removed itself from the Defence Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) programme to build a winged first-stage reusable rocket, called the Experimental Spaceplane-1 (XS-1), aka the “Phantom Express”. DARPA accepts that with the withdrawal of Boeing, the project is now cancelled.

Following Phase 1 study contracts in 2014, Boeing beat Masten Space Systems and Northrop Grumman in a competition for the Phase 2/Phase 3 contracts to build and fly the vertically launched space plane’s first stage in May 2017. The company was awarded a US$146 million contract, paid in stages. Boeing also invested its own money in the programme. Masten Space Systems was later given the role of building the Zephyr expendable upper stage.

The Phantom Express was an experimental spaceplane and the Zephyr booster was planned to have the capability to deliver small satellites into orbit for the US Military, with a flight rate/cadence as frequently as once a day. The spaceplane was to have been powered by a Liquid Hydrogen/Liquid Oxygen (Lox)-burning Aerojet Rocketdyne AR-22 engine, based on Space Shuttle Main Engine technology. Test firings of this engine have reportedly gone well.

During an operational flight the 30m long spaceplane would achieve a velocity of Mach 10 before releasing an upper stage to take a satellite payload into orbit. The combination was planned to have a payload to low Earth orbit of 1,360 kg.

Not to be: The Phantom Express/Experimental Space Plane (XS-1) project has now been cancelled. Courtesy: Boeing

Comment by David Todd:  The exact reasons for Boeing’s withdrawal and the project’s failure have not been disclosed. One suspects that financial struggles at Boeing are part of the story. The reusable rocket plane might also have some technical issues as it struggled to achieve its payload/cost/fast reuse objectives. For example, the XS-1 may have been too heavy (wing structures and associated thermal protection systems tend to be weighty and complicated), and difficult to integrate (as reusable two-stage winged vehicles are liable to be).

While the withdrawal is very embarrassing for Boeing, DARPA should also be ashamed. This failure just adds to the list of launch project failures that DARPA has had over the years. It has spent hundreds of millions of US taxpayers’ money on launch vehicle projects with little to show for it. A prime example came in late 2015 when DARPA’s ALASA (Airborne Launch Assist Space Access) programme to launch a small rocket launcher from an F-15 jet fighter was ended after series of ground explosions. While its drop-off fuel tank and canted engines’ design had some merit, DARPA found out what any 7th grade space cadet could have told it beforehand: mixing liquid fuel and oxidiser in a single tank was a dangerous thing to do. Before that DARPA had launch project failures with its RASCAL (Responsive Access, Small Cargo, Affordable Launch) and FALCON (Force Application and Launch from Continental US) programmes.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Boeing and Aerojet Rocketdyne to build DARPA two stage reusable spaceplane

The U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) has selected Boeing to build its new part-reusable experimental spaceplane (XS-1). Called the Read more

Boeing’s concept for XS-1 gets more DARPA research money as does Northrop Grumman and Masten

In August 2015, the Boeing/Blue Origin team led by Boeing received US$6.5 million additional funding from DARPA to continue with its XS-1 design concept for Read more

DARPA contracts with Telesat for two satellites as part of its Blackjack initiative

An American subsidiary, Telesat U.S. Services, of Canadian global FSS operator Telesat was awarded a satellite production contract on 14 Read more

Bitten by past failures DARPA chooses proven Northrop Grumman for satellite servicing demo contract

Having licked its wounds over past investment failures – the ending of the XS-1 reusable rocket programme after Boeing’s unilateral Read more

Electron rocket launches R3D2 antenna technology test satellite for DARPA

An Electron rocket built and operated by RocketLab lifted off from the Mahia Penisula launch site in New Zealand at Read more

DARPA makes Electron launch order for its small R3D2 test satellite…and asks Airbus DS to develop small bus for “Blackjack” programme

The US Defence Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) has made a launch order to Rocket Lab for an Electron launch of its Read more

As thriving Raytheon waits for Space Sensing Layer constellation down-select it looks across the pond for more opportunities

While the US firm Raytheon is best known for its missiles’ business – its Sidewinder infra-red “heat-seeking” air-to-air missile being Read more

DARPA gets to test Reaction Engines’ heat exchanger…as genius inventor Alan Bond retires from firm

In September, Reaction Engines Inc, the US subsidiary of the Oxfordshire, England-based Reaction Engines Limited, announced that it had won a Read more

Recent Posts

  • Telesat moves to smaller LEO comsat constellation as it demos its signals over India
  • SpaceX launches 59 satellites on its Transporter-5 flight of Falcon 9
  • A busy May for Musk: mulling over buying Twitter, fighting a sexual impropriety allegation, as SpaceX sells stock for funding
  • China launches three communication satellites on Long March 2C
  • Atlas V launches Starliner OFT-2 test flight to ISS but spacecraft has a shaky orbital insertion (Updated)

Categories

Archives

Tags

nasaspacexecoreviewsissesaArianespacevideochina25virgin galacticULAfalcon 9RoscosmosDGAaviation weekaresIGTsoyuzawardsBeidouspacewalkspaceSatellite broadcastingInternational Space StationevamoonrussiaCargo Return VehiclemarsblogresearchBlue OriginboeingAirbus DSimpactspaceshiptwomarshyperboladelayjaxademocratISROobamaorionhypertextrocketgoogle lunar prizelunarVegalaunchbarack obamaconstellationtourismStarlinkfiguresnorthEutelsatRocket LabFalcon 9v1.2FT Block 5SESspaceflightfundedOneWebnode 2Raymond LygoromeExpress MD-22009thales alenia spaceAtlas Vss2dassault aviationwk22008aviationLucyElon MuskradioukLockheed MartinIntelsatmissiledocking portexplorationtestsuborbitalinternetsstlsts-122China Manned Space Engineeringmissile defensecotsgalileoflight2010Ariane 5newspaperspaceportspace tourismExpress AMU 1altairAriane 5 ECAbuildspace stationshuttleProton MSLSEuropean Space AgencyCosmosIntelsat 23scaled compositesinternational astronautical congressVirgin Orbitnew yorkElectronrulesbudgethanleyspace shuttleatvVietnamLauncherOneshenzhoucongressMojaveboldenAriane 6Orbital ATKNorthrop GrummanGuiana Space CenteriacksclawsSpace Systems/LoralcnesUK Space AgencyInmarsatnew shepardILSprotonUS Air Forcesoyuz 2-1aTalulah RileyApolloLong March 4CLong March 4BeuSkylonlanderpictureAstriumusadarpaastronautdragonbasefiveeventLong March 2CSSL50thAprilSNCinterviewlunar landerSea LaunchfalconWednesdaycustomerlinkatlantissuccessor7Space InsuranceLong March 2D/2griffinnewsenergiaorbiterhuman

Contact us

Tel UK: +44 (0) 1858 778 006
Tel USA: +1 646 233 4874
Email: info@seradata.com
22 West End, Welford, Northampton, NN6 6HJ, UK

Site Map

  • Home
  • Products
    • SpaceTrak
  • Conference
    • Seradata Space Conference 2021
    • Previous Conference 2019
  • Resources
    • Launch Market
    • Launch & Space Insurance
    • Satellite Reliability
    • Space Domain Awareness
    • Satellite Market Analysis
    • Satellite Frequencies & Spectrum Analysis
  • About us
    • Our Team
  • Contact us
  • SSI News
  • SpaceTrak Login
Seradata

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • RSS
© Seradata. Website Terms | Privacy Statement | Cookies Policy | Seradata and SpaceTrak are registered trademarks Seradata is registered in England, Company Number 8750033