Analysis: After ABS-2 and Antares/Cygnus Orb-3 claims, space insurers face white knuckle ride (Corrected)

by | Oct 29, 2014 | International Space Station, Launches, Space Insurance | 0 comments

A formal insurance claim for US$214 million has been made for the loss of a satellite telecommunications beam on the ABS-2 communications payload. The failure was first discovered in July when a Ku-band beam fault on spacecraft led to outage affecting its customers.   This expected insurance loss, and the subsequent Antares/Cygnus Orb-3 launch failure-related insurance claim of US$48 million, has led some insurers to fret that the market will again fall into loss as it did last year.

Industry observers noted that the ABS-2 claim was surprisingly large given that the total insured value of the spacecraft was US$450 million. However, while the faulty Ku-band beam was only one of ten beams carried by the spacecraft,  the Russian beam was insured for a high value as it was of high commercial importance.

As a reflection of the value of the beam, according to Space News, it was actually co- owned by the satellite capacity leasing firm GT Satellite Systems S.A. of Moscow and Luxembourg which part bought it in a 2011 deal for US$125 million.

According to Seradata’s figures, the two expected losses brings the total of insurance losses (pending final agreements) to around US$650 million for the year. This figure may rise a little further if a claim by Urthecast for loss of business related to an imaging payload on the International Space Station, and its faulty tracking table, is accepted.

Gross premium levels received to date are just about balancing potential losses, with gross premium receipts (before broker deductions) estimated by industry sources to be circa US$630 million. While premium rates have risen slightly for some risks (Proton launches for example) others remain depressed mainly due to the large capacity available with more space insurers than ever participating in the space insurance class.

A Proton launch failure in May, which resulted in an insurance loss of US$217 million for the launch destruction of Express AM-4R, both raised premium rates for Proton launches, but also depressed the likely total of premium due to delays to subsequent Proton launches.  The resulting failure inquiry which lasted several months, caused Proton, one of the mainstays of commercial launches, to be stood down while it took place.

The inaccurate launch of Express AM-6 by a Proton in October is unlikely to cause insurance loss. However it may yet lead to another hiatus in the Proton launch schedule.

Assuming that the Proton is allowed to fly, estimates for the eventual total of premium receipts for the year are currently in the region of US$750 million.  In other words, if space insurers are to make a profit on a calendar underwriting basis, they are hoping that there will be no more significant losses in the last two months of 2014. A “white knuckle ride” indeed.

Last year (2013) was a “losing year” on a calendar basis with gross premium being estimated at circa US$700 million, but with losses equating to US$814 million.

A full listing of  space insurance claims and losses is available on Seradata’s SpaceTrak database. For more information, contact info@seradata.com.

Post Script:  In an unrelated personnel change,  Seradata understands that long-time space insurance executive, Jeffery Temple-Heald, has left the space insurance arm of AIG Europe. James Straker-Nesbit is expected to take over the reins there under Paul Aitcheson who moves from Sciemus.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Antares 130 launch fails in explosion destroying Cygnus cargo craft and damaging launch pad (Updated)

The launch of the Orbital Sciences Antares 130 rocket carrying the Cygnus Orb-3 cargo craft to the International Space Station Read more

Something strange? While Antares 110 hit its mark most of its payloads are no longer in orbit

While Orbital Sciences Corp was rightly congratulated for the successful launch of its Antares 110 launch vehicle, there is something Read more

Antares launch vehicle makes successful maiden launch

After some days of delay variously caused by a premature separation of an umbilical and high level winds, new Antares Read more

Express AM-6 has had its Ka-payload turned off due to thermal issue

The Russian Satellite Communications Company (RSCC) has confirmed that it has turned off the Ka-band payload of the communications satellite Read more

China loses another: Long March 3B launch fails and Palapa-N1 falls into the drink

Having had a launch setback with its new Long March 7A (CZ-7A) rocket in March, it looked unlikely that China Read more

Aon buy-out of Willis Towers Watson still likely to go ahead despite coronavirus

On 9 March it was announced that Aon the World's second largest insurance broker in the world would by Willis Read more

Coronavirus Analysis: How is the outbreak affecting space industry? (Updated)

Whether you call it coronavirus or COVID-19 you cannot avoid this “Elephant in the Room”, which is affecting much of Read more

Thaicom 5 transfers customers after anomaly…likely insurance loss

It has been reported that customers on the Thaicom 5 communications satellite have been moved to other satellites following a Read more

Categories

Archives

Tags