Analysis: Russian space agency Roscosmos is merged into supersize space company – but is it a good idea?

by | Jan 29, 2015 | China, NASA, Russia | 0 comments

In a further indication that Russia seems intent on going back to a Soviet-style command structure, the Russian Government has approved the merger of the Russian Space Agency, Roscosmos, with mega-corporation United Rocket and Space Corp (URSC).

Originally, it had been planned that Roscosmos would remain a separate “commissioning” agency, with URSC – formed in 2014 through the consolidation of most of Russia’s space companies – being the executor of the agency’s plans.   However, in a change of thinking, it has been decided to make URSC and Roscosmos one and the same.

It is expected that, following the merger, the current head of Roscosmos, Oleg Ostapenko, will make way for the current URSC leader, Igor Komarov.  Instead, Ostpenko will take a role in the new organisation, probably as head of one of the subsidiary corporations under Komarov.

As a rule, private firms tend to be better run and more efficient and competitive than state-run operations.  While this efficiency mainly benefits the private firms’ shareholders, customers win as well if the market is truly competitive.

However, it can also be true that sometimes “state run” is best.   This is usually where private industry cannot be trusted not to abuse its position in a monopoly or cartel-like situation. The water and energy utilities and the railways come to mind, where experience shows that even state-appointed market regulators are often too ineffectual to prevent such abuse.  The other instance is where a public service non-commercial ethic is required e.g. the armed forces and rescue services (take note those UK Government ministers who saw fit to privatise Air-Sea rescue).

However, neither of these cases really holds true for the latest Russian move, even if space has an acknowledged military bias. Consolidating the entire Russian space industry into one all-powerful firm is, therefore, probably a mistake. Merging its overseeing/commissioning agency into this body looks doubly misguided.  While such a structure could theoretically remove duplication and make major economy-of-scale savings, in reality such massive state-run enterprises usually turn into uncompetitive, bureaucratic and corrupt organisations offering poor quality products and services: a disease already afflicting some of Russia’s state-run space enterprises.

A better model is in USA where private firms bid for funds from a public commissioning agency (NASA, DoD etc) for the execution of space projects. The American taxpayer has not always benefited from this approach, usually due to overly-cosy relationships between government and the major industry players, or because the private side manages to pull the wool over the eyes of inexpert public employees. Nevertheless, NASA’s recent commissioning successes with its commercial space transportation programmes show just how well private and public entities can work together* so long as the contracts are properly run.   Even Communist China has woken up to the danger of monopolistic state-run firms running space contracts. It now tries to ensure that its design academies and other organisations compete against each other when they can.

*Excepting NASA’s short-termism in its final choice of commercial crew winners.

 

 

 

 

 

 

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

US sanctions SPACETY for supplying radar imagery to Russian Wagner Group in Ukraine

Just as Ukraine's military campaign has been supported by US commercial spacecraft operating firms — with SpaceX and Maxar providing Read more

Tianwen 1 mission’s Zhurong-1 Mars rover may have expired in its sleep

SpaceNews reports (quoting the South China Morning Post) that the Zhurong 1 Mars rover as part of the Tianwen 1 Read more

NASA goes Nuclear Thermal as it plans to launch engine on DARPA’s DRACO project test mission in 2027

Nuclear Thermal rocket propulsion has been mooted since the 1960s. The idea is to use nuclear power to heat rocket Read more

First ISS spacewalk for 2023 completed

On 20 January 2023 JAXA astronaut Koichi Wakata and NASA astronaut Nicole Mann opened the Quest airlock hatch at 1312 Read more

APSTAR 6E orbit raising is slowed after faults stymy use of main kick motor engine

The APT Satellite Holdings-owned APSTAR 6E HTS communications satellite, which was placed into an initial orbit by a Chinese Long Read more

China deploys 14 satellites on Long March-2D rocket

The Chinese sent 14 new satellites into orbit on a Long March-2D/2 (CZ-2D/2) rocket at 0314 GMT on 15 January. Read more

Long March 2C launches small GEO comsat APSTAR 6E HTS using a “Kick Stage”

China's Long March 2C/3 (CZ-2C/3) rocket has been modified with a additional kick stage attached to the satellite to launch Read more

Soyuz MS-23 to replace leak-damaged Soyuz MS-22 for crew return

Following a radiator leak on 15 December, Roscosmos, in agreement with NASA and other International Space Station (ISS) partners, has Read more

Categories

Archives