Ares I Electric TVC dreams

by | Sep 5, 2008 | Ares | 2 comments

On 5 August NASA released a pre-solicitation synopsis for a Request for Proposal (RFP) for its Ares [I crew launch vehicle solid rocket booster (SRB) first-stage] electric thrust vector control (TVC) prototype risk reduction system requirement – more easily written than read

Its another example of how the CLV’s first-stage will bear little resemblance to the original Shuttle SRB. From memory, I think, a change to an electric TVC would literally mean the only original bit of the Shuttle SRB design to remain will be the steel segment casings

For years TVC electromechanical actuators (EMA) have been investigated because NASA believes they are lighter, cleaner, possibly even safer in their operation, and are easier to maintain than the hydrazine powered hydraulics used by Shuttle today

An early example of EMA technology application is the Redstone missile in the 1950’s. In this system an electrical chain drive actuated air fins for aerodynamic steering.

NASA was conducting research into electric TVCs almost 20-years ago and Marshall Spaceflight Center produced this report in 1993

The key word to focus on today is lighter. If you are adding mass to the vehicle with an oscillation mitigation system then you might want to think about ditching that dirty great hydraulic system, yes?

But another thought comes to me. NASA is talking about an active mass damper system that will need power. I wonder if there are benefits in having an electric TVC not only for mass savings but in terms of sharing the power source that will enable the two systems?

With NASA concluding 20-years ago that Shuttle readiness could have been shortened by 10-days by avoiding the TVC hydraulic system prep with an all-electric operation you wonder why they didn’t opt for EMAs for Ares I in the first place?

And then another mystery, as the agency suspends the EMA/TVC solicitation. “NASA has determined to put the subject acquisition on hold pending further agency reviews. It is anticipated that a decision will be made no later than October 1, 2008,” the agency announced on 28 August. Isn’t that after the Ares I stack preliminary design review ends…?

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Skylab and Space Shuttle astronaut Owen Garriott passes away

Former NASA astronaut Owen Garriott has passed away at his home in Huntsville Alabama at the age of 88.  Garriott Read more

On a lighter note: making it idiot proof

In a variation of the “garbage in…garbage out” warning about computers, your correspondent sometimes likes to jest that while the excellent Seradata SpaceTrak Read more

Liberty Media to take over Formula One motor racing but “all subscription” revenues may eventually become as thin as its starved drivers
Liberty Media to take over Formula One motor racing but “all subscription” revenues may eventually become as thin as its starved drivers

While the FIFA World Cup and the Olympic Games remain unmatched as individual world TV and satellite broadcasting events, in third, Read more

On a sadder note: We say goodbye to Shuttle launch director Gene Thomas and to comedy writing genius Caroline Aherne
On a sadder note: We say goodbye to Shuttle launch director Gene Thomas and to comedy writing genius Caroline Aherne

Former Space Shuttle launch director, Gene Thomas, passed away as an octogenarian in June. Thomas was probably the most unfortunate of NASA launch directors Read more

Makers of well-regarded Shuttle investigation docu-drama are sued
Makers of well-regarded Shuttle investigation docu-drama are sued

While the BBC/Discovery Communications Docu-Drama The Challenger (aka The Challenger Disaster) was generally well regarded, with critics especially praising William Hurt's performance Read more

On a sadder note:  First US Female astronaut Dr Sally Ride passes away
On a sadder note: First US Female astronaut Dr Sally Ride passes away

We are sad to report that Dr Sally Ride, the first US woman to fly in space has passed away Read more

Space Shuttle Enterprise prototype arrives in New York
Space Shuttle Enterprise prototype arrives in New York

The Space Shuttle Enterprise has been moved out of Washtington D.C. now that the city has the real thing: the Read more

Space Shuttle flies again – at least in LEGO form
Space Shuttle flies again – at least in LEGO form

While using helium balloons to carry GPS tracked cameras to image the "edge of space" is now being regularly done Read more

Categories

Archives