As Putin formally starts SLS-ski, NASA notes that SLS first flight is likely to be delayed (Corrected)

by | Sep 3, 2014 | NASA, Russia, Seradata News, SLS | 0 comments

While Russia’s President Vladimir Putin might have more controversial foreign and military issues to contend with, he has found the time to formally sign the authorisation for the development of a Russian SLS-equivalent super-heavy lift launch vehicle which, like its US opposite number, will have two versions: a 70 metric ton initial version and a later 130-150 metric ton version.  According to Russian Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin development of the new rocket will take place once the new Angara series is completed.

On the other side of the fence, having announced that SLS had passed its key design and funding reviews, NASA surprised many by declaring that the first launch of SLS could be delayed by 11 months.  Officially it said that the EM-1 mission, which was to be a trans-lunar test of the Orion capsule/service module combination in unmanned state, would be delayed from December 2017 to a likely launch date of November 2018. A first manned flight would happen about four years later.

Development of the SLS has gone much better than expected – especially when compared with NASA’s traumatic experience with Project Constellation’s Ares I and V launch vehicle designs. NASA has previously hinted that a lack of funding is hampering their progress towards this first flight, notably in the development of an interim upper stage based on Delta IV technology.

The US Government Accounting Office (GAO) believes that the programme will need another US$400 million to achieve its launch objective for the initial 70 metric ton to LEO version of SLS.

The Key Decision Point C (KDP-C) review, which SLS has just passed, estimated that the remaining costs of the programme up to the first launch will be US$7 billion, adding to the US$8 billion already spent on it and relevant parts of the Project Constellation forerunner.

While the EM-1 flight delay is thought to be due to funding issues, some have suggested that the real “choke point” to the timeline of the first flight might be the delayed development of the Orion Service Module, which is based on the European ATV cargo craft.   This has been denied by NASA.  The Orion service module is being designed and built using European Space Agency funding as a way for ESA to pay off its International Space Station debts to NASA.  Nevertheless, despite being based on an already-flying system, development difficulties have left the service module’s development months behind schedule.

Meanwhile, critics note that in the course of its own plans to land humans on Mars, the privateer outfit, SpaceX, is planning to build an as-yet unnamed super-heavy-lift rocket which may be able to carry twice as much into orbit as SLS, effectively making SLS redundant for Mars exploration.

Comment by David Todd:  Seradata’s analysis is that the SLS would instead be ideal for simple Apollo-style manned lunar missions if not for more extensive lunar exploration.  However, the Moon seems not to be on NASA’s agenda as its leaders prefer to go for an asteroid retrieval mission.  Nevertheless, our analysis has always been that NASA would probably need a “bigger boat than SLS” which is actually too small to be used effectively for manned Mars missions.

As it is, Elon Musk with his SpaceX whopper-booster, is at least keeping the United States of America at the head of the space race for a manned Mars landing.  While Musk has shown no interest in lunar exploration, any plans for a US lunar base would also benefit from having a rocket even larger than SLS.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

SLS Wet Dress Rehearsal is dogged by delays which eventually postpones it

The much delayed SLS Heavy-lift Launch Vehicle (HLV) due to take NASA astronauts back to the Moon won’t be going Read more

SLS saves itself with successful full-duration engine firing but its career may still be short

NASA’s much delayed and very expensive SLS heavy-lift launch vehicle (HLV) has coming under renewed criticism as SpaceX’s partly reusable Read more

NASA paints a brave face on SLS engine test failure (Updated)

NASA might have said that it wanted a minimum of 250 seconds' worth of engine firing plus gimbal movements to Read more

Despite anti-democratic attempt to storm its government, the USA gets a new President – with Senate power which is bad news for SLS

After politically traumatic events in Washington DC, the inauguration of President elect Joe Biden and his Vice President elect Kamala Read more

Bridenstine notes public-private partnerships in NASA push to develop crewed lunar landers

At the 35th Space Symposium in Colorado on 9 April, NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine put some meat on the bare Read more

Pence commits NASA to human return to the Moon before 2024 as it goes cold on further development of SLS

The Trump Administration has signalled a change of space policy on a human return to the Moon. Addressing the National Space Read more

Analysis: In the Great Space Race China retakes lead for human lunar return but USA is still favourite for Mars

While the original space race between superpowers - the USA and Soviet Union during the 1960s - was effectively ended Read more

NASA budget: WFIRST mission is cancelled while ISS time is marked – but SLS is thrown a lifeline

NASA’s acting administrator, Robert Lightfoot, revealed in a speech at NASA Marshall Spaceflight Center at Huntsville, Alabama, that NASA’s budget had received Read more