Aviation Week reveals that Dream Chaser missed out on new NASA commercial crew funding over schedule concerns

by | Oct 16, 2014 | Commercial human spaceflight, NASA, Seradata News, Technology | 0 comments

The industry magazine and web news channel, Aviation Week and Space Technology, has disclosed that the Sierra Nevada Corp (SNC) bid to obtain NASA Commercial Crew Transportation Capability (CctCap) funding lost out to Boeing and SpaceX because of concerns over schedule delays.  An internal NASA document signed by NASA Associate Administrator, William Gerstenmaier, notes that the Dream Chaser was dropped because of his concerns that the design had the “lowest level of maturity”, with significantly more “technical work and critical design decisions” ahead resulting in increased “schedule uncertainty”.

A late-September protest over the decision by SNC to the US Government Accounting Office (GAO) temporarily caused all commercial crew capsule work to cease at Boeing and SpaceX.  A decision on the protest is due in January next year. However, NASA quickly ordered Boeing and SpaceX to restart, stating that national interests and schedule concerns meant that the work had to continue.

SNC has asked the US Court of Federal Claims to prevent this work from carrying on until the protest has been dealt with.  However, the court declined to do this.

Comment by David Todd:  This column has long noted that as a more sophisticated aerodynamic vehicle, Sierra Nevada Corp’s Dream Chaser, would be the last of the commercial crew competitors to become a working spacecraft. In this regard, Gerstenmaier is correct inhis assessment.  However, his decision to drop Dream Chaser altogether is a mistake, as its lifting body “mini-shuttle” is much the best long term design.  It its better in terms of probable operational cost, low ‘g’ re-entry performance, landing safety, and cross-range capability.

As such, it would have been more logical for NASA to have chosen one of the “low schedule risk” capsule designs as the “insurance” (our choice would have been Boeing’s CST-100) to pair with the slower-to-develop, but ultimately better, Dream Chaser. Instead Gerstenmaier chose to fund both the Boeing CST-100 capsule and the new manned version of SpaceX’s Dragon capsule which, by the way, may take longer to develop than expected, given its new, high risk, rocket landing technique.

Gerstenmaier is retiring soon, but it will be NASA and the rest of the space community that will have to live for years with the effects of one of his last decisions in office.  And a short-sighted and wrong one at that.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Proton-M launches Elektro-L N4 weather sat for Russia

A Proton-M/Block DM-03 launch vehicle was successfully launched from Baikonur Cosmodrome, near Tyuratam in Kazakhstan at 0912 GMT on 5 Read more

SSLV failure cause: Violent second stage separation triggered chain of events which prevented SSLV final stage burn to stable orbit

The failure investigation set up by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) into the launch failure of the maiden flight Read more

South Korea confirms shift of two missions from Russian launchers; Kompsat 6 goes to Arianespace and CAS500-2 goes back to international market

The South Korean vice-minister for Science, Oh Tae-seog, announced on 1 February 2023 that they had selected an Arianespace Vega Read more

SpaceX launches another batch of Starlinks plus ION-SCV9 delivery spacecraft testing separation system

A Falcon 9v1.2FT Block 5 was launched from the Vandenberg Space Force base in California at 1615 GMT on 31 Read more

US sanctions SPACETY for supplying radar imagery to Russian Wagner Group in Ukraine

Just as Ukraine's military campaign has been supported by US commercial spacecraft operating firms — with SpaceX and Maxar providing Read more

Tianwen 1 mission’s Zhurong-1 Mars rover may have expired in its sleep

SpaceNews reports (quoting the South China Morning Post) that the Zhurong 1 Mars rover as part of the Tianwen 1 Read more

Tom Cruise may have saved cinema industry with Top Gun-Maverick but he has even higher movie plans with space station studio module now ordered

While action film actor Tom Cruise has his detractors, you cannot say he is not successful. Recently starring in the Read more

NASA goes Nuclear Thermal as it plans to launch engine on DARPA’s DRACO project test mission in 2027

Nuclear Thermal rocket propulsion has been mooted since the 1960s. The idea is to use nuclear power to heat rocket Read more