Constellation: Hyperbola’s journey to nowhere

by | Apr 26, 2010 | Ares, Constellation, exploration, NASA, Orion, Seradata News | 1 comment

When this blogger saw the headline of this 30 March article by Aviation Week’s senior space editor Frank Morring it seemed that the “program of record” that dare not speak its name had finally broken cover and spoken to the media after a self imposed vow of silence

But alas no, even Aviation Week’s article had no detail on what was going on with Constellation and so there was still everything to play for, time to hit the phones and email – again

Now, by way of leaked emails, it seems that Constellation’s management are preparing for any eventuality

But way back at the beginning on the 1 February the newly published fiscal year 2011 (1 October 2010 to 30 September 2011) budget request for NASA had notably continued funding the Moon return Constellation programme until 2012, even if it was cancelled this year

This blogger decided that whatever anyone thought of the programme’s merit it was worth giving the space agency a call. A call to find out how the Ares and Orion and lunar surface systems project offices were planning to spend in FY2010 and FY2011 the $8 billion odd budgeted for for Constellation

After all, exploration mission directorate associate administrator Doug Cooke had told us media during a 1 February week telecon that capabilities developed during Constellation would be considered, and probably used, for president Barack Obama’s flexible path to all sorts of places including Mars at various times in the future

It was a journey, a telecommunications expedition, that at the beginning seemed to bear fruit. One thing this blogger did get confirmed is that the Altair project office had not been “defunded” – as reported elsewhere – but its activities had become part of the lunar surface systems project. Then out of the blue NASA released a short statement about how the Constellation programme, as a whole, had passed its preliminary design review. Other than that though the going was not good

Carrots were dangled about better times to talk in the near future with suggestions of personnel changes. One came away from the phone calls with public affairs wondering what could possibly be going on or not, as the case maybe

One thing this blog believed it did know, due to statements by NASA personnel at the 60th International Astronautical Congress in south Korea, was that some of the Constellation team were investigating heavy lift concepts because NASA administrator Charles Bolden wanted them too. However this was back when heavy lift wasn’t a decision to be left to 2015

But that was 2009 and this was 2010 and as Bolden faltered, and blubbed, at every Congressional hearing and the anti-Obama budget rhetoric got louder any hope of talking to the people running Constellation’s project offices seemed to get more distant

Whatever programme or project anyone works if its taxpayer funded the general assumption in free societes is that transparency is a given. What that taxpayer money is being spent on should be disclosed. This blogger recalls a testy exchange during one Constellation telecon between a US journalist and a project office manager when the manager declined to give a figure for development expenditure

Constellation has been ignored by much of the media for some time now because of the assumption that it is a lame duck, a dead parrot even. But it is an expired parrot that will eat up billions of dollars even if its cancelled and now we know its Orion crew exploration vehicle won’t be – and those that declared the Ares I dead are even having to report that it might not be

It is clear that the political process to resolve the logjam of vehement Congressional opposition to Obama’s plan is going to last for the rest of this year. It is also highly likely that the FY2011 budget will not be passed by 30 September, meaning NASA has to operate on FY2010 funding

Six months plus of silence from a programme that is spending hundreds of millions of dollars a month is not acceptable. Quarterely videos are not sufficient and the Constellation team should restart the regular telecons that have previously been organised. Constellation has not been cancelled its funding is still the law and until Obama’s FY2011 budget is passed intact that situation is not going to change

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

Ares I is not dead: It’s NASA’s FY2010 budget request again…

This re-tweeted tweet care of the well informed Jeff Foust and this article in The Huntsville Times suggests that like Read more

PICTURES: Tiangong model, cargo spacecraft, station in-orbit assembly

This graphic is of a cargo spacecraft design that China's manned space engineering programme is developing from its Tiangong spacelab. Read more

EXCLUSIVE PICTURES: Virgin Galactic LauncherOne designs revealed

This design for Virgin Galactic's mini satellite launching rocket LauncherOne was shown by the company's small satellite launch general manager Read more

VIDEO: #iac2009 Space agencies talk ISS future

Watch this video from the Internatonal Astronautical Congress in Daejeon, Korea where the future of the International Space Station was Read more

VIDEO: #iac2009 Major space agencys’ chiefs talk exploration

Watch this video from the Internatonal Astronautical Congress in Daejeon, Korea first plenary session where heads of the world's major Read more

VIDEO: #iac2009 Civilian access to space session

Watch this video of the Internatonal Astronautical Congress in Daejeon, Korea where Virgin Galactic president Will Whitehorn, Sierra Nevada vice Read more

WORLD EXCLUSIVE PICTURES: China’s space station concept

These Chinese space station concepts were presented by China Manned Space Engineering deputy general designer Wang Zhonggui at International Astronautical Read more

Bolden talks frankly: Ares I might be dead but so are EELVs

NASA had told Hyperbola its administrator Charles Bolden was not going to be available here in Daejeon, Korea but a Read more