Is Obama’s NASA returning to 1970’s IPP option one sans Shuttle?

by | Feb 11, 2010 | Seradata News | 7 comments

A US space agency has undertaken a major manned Moon programme, a new administration is not prepared to fund it any further, vehicles are being cancelled and a report provides options for what happens next, sound familiar? It should it is what NASA has gone through over the last year and it is what happened, more or less, in 1970

Or it is if this history blog is correct in its re-telling – discovered by this blogger via English language Indian tweeter Pradx – of that key moment in US space policy when the Richard Nixon administration ended Apollo

According to the Beyond Apollo blog site Nixon’s NASA was presented with five options for what the agency could do next as the Moon programme was wound down

The fourth and fifth of the five options saw the Saturn V production line continued and rather like the Review of US human spaceflight plans’ report an unconstrained budget provides the heavy lift vehicle for human exploration. The third option was a robotics programme with landings on the Moon and eventually Mars

Options one and two were essentially the same using space “tugs” that are in-space vehicles that cycle back and forth through cislunar space but only one of these options had space stations. The Beyond Apollo website summarises the first option thus:

The [Integrated Program Plan] had NASA bringing online its Earth Orbit Space Station (EOSS) and winged reusable Earth-to-Orbit Shuttle (EOS) by 1977. The EOSS would serve as base for reusable piloted Tugs and reusable Nuclear Shuttles. When mated to a Nuclear Shuttle, a Tug would be capable of reaching the moon. NASA planned to use this infrastructure in 1981 to establish a Lunar Orbit Space Station (LOSS) with a propellant depot. A Lunar Surface Base (LSB) would follow no earlier than 1985 (see images at the top of this post).

Clearly there is no Shuttle with the Obama plan but the EOSS, or as we call it the International Space Station, is there and a nuclear shuttle could always be the VASIMR. Note the use of propellant depots. The blog goes on to say that:

Scherer’s Option 2 was a “Shuttle/Tug lunar program.” The EOS and a reusable piloted Tug without EOSS, LOSS, and Nuclear Shuttle would enable piloted lunar orbit and landing missions by 1979, he told Culbertson. He stressed that, to enable this option, lunar mission requirements would need to play a role in the drafting of Shuttle and Tug sizing and performance requirements. As envisioned by Scherer, two Tugs would suffice to place astronauts in lunar orbit, while four Tugs would allow astronauts to land on the moon. A pair of landings at a single site would be sufficient to establish a temporary “minibase” by 1982.

To have a mini-base by 1982 when in 1970 there was no Shuttle or tug(s) of any description is quite an ambitious target. This second option does require a Shuttle, which NASA won’t have come 2011, but it shows that the tugs were seen as modular vehicles that together enabled different capabilities

The reality for an Obama spaceflight vision, if it survives Congress and if it had a similar architecture to option one, would probably be a 2032 manned lunar landing. The idea of ISS becoming a low Earth orbit shipyard and sending in-space vehicles out to the Moon not only matches the proposed flexible path but it also matches European Space Agency and Russian Federal Space Agency thinking on how an international exploration strategy could work – even with an orbiting lunar space station

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

Neil Armstrong is remembered at Washington service

A national act of remembrance for Neil Armstrong was held at the Washington National Cathedral on the morning (local time) Read more

ANALYSIS: Isle of Man rises to fourth favourite in manned race back to the moon (Updated)

Two years ago, the space team at the Ascend consultancy (now part of Flightglobal) did an analysis on which nation Read more

Obama space plan debate sees no sign of a victor

Despite the grandiose visit to Kennedy Space Center president Barack Obama's space plan is still being divisive even with the Read more

VIDEO: Lunar Lander simulator film with narration

This video appears to have been taken during a presentation that was screening a film with no apparent sound from Read more

Burt Rutan responds to Buzz Aldrin Wall Street Journal op-ed

This sounds fine thru the lens of my friend Buzz Aldrin. However, the reality is that the new plan has Read more

CONTRACT WATCH: A new feature of Hyperbola

From now on Hyperbola will be posting contract announcements with either the entire press release text in the post or Read more

NASA’s Orion gets its heat shield, at last

NASA announced yesterday that the reformulation of the Apollo programme's Avcoat has been selected for its Orion Crew Exploration Vehicle Read more

NASA: Apollo@40 but nothing for 16 July?

Go here to find NASA's Apollo 11 40th anniversary website and click through to this to find a document with Read more




nasaspacexecoreviewsissesaArianespacevideochina25virgin galacticULAfalcon 9RoscosmosDGAaviation weekaresIGTsoyuzawardsBeidouspacespacewalkSatellite broadcastingmoonInternational Space StationevaCargo Return VehiclerussiaBlue OriginmarsblogresearchboeingimpactAirbus DSspaceshiptwomarshyperboladelayjaxademocratISROobamaorionhypertextrocketgoogle lunar prizelunarVegalaunchbarack obamaconstellationStarlinktourismfiguresEutelsatnorthRocket LabSESspaceflightfundedFalcon 9v1.2FT Block 5OneWebnode 2Raymond Lygorome2009Express MD-2thales alenia spacess2dassault aviationAtlas VaviationLucy2008wk2radioIntelsatukElon MuskLockheed Martinexplorationtestmissiledocking portsstlinternetsuborbitalsts-122China Manned Space Engineering2010newspapercotsgalileoAriane 5flightmissile defensespaceportspace tourismExpress AMU 1Ariane 5 ECAaltairbuildspace stationProton MSLSshuttleIntelsat 23scaled compositesVirgin OrbitCosmosinternational astronautical congressEuropean Space AgencyrulesElectronbudgetnew yorkhanleyLauncherOneshenzhouspace shuttleatvVietnamboldenAriane 6congressMojaveGuiana Space CenterNorthrop GrummanOrbital ATKiackscSpace Systems/LoralUK Space AgencylawscnesUS Air ForceInmarsatprotonnew shepardILSTalulah RileyLong March 4Csoyuz 2-1aApollousadarpaSkylonastronautAstriumeudragonlanderLong March 4BpicturebaseeventSSLfiveLong March 2CAprilinterviewWednesdaySNC50thfalconlunar landerSea Launchlink7successorcustomeratlantisSpace InsuranceLong March 2D/2conferencenational space symposiumorbiterTelesat15