Ares I not dead: Evidence EELV report’s “facts” are ULA claims

by | Jun 21, 2009 | Seradata News | 8 comments

Thumbnail image for delta iv.jpg

credit United Launch Alliance / caption: In 2007 the Delta IV launches the USAF DSP-23 satellite

Watching the NASAtv webcast repeats of United Launch Alliance (ULA) president and chief executive Michael Gass’ presentation and the Aerospace Corporation’s Gary Pulliam explanation of the Delta IV study, it became clearer that the original (NSF) report was based on ULA’s argument (was it me or was Gass very nervous?). The ULA, NSF similarities are:

  • the selling point for the Boeing Delta IV Heavy is its alleged 20% performance margin
  • the need for the still-in-development RS-68A to achieve the 20% performance margin
  • the claim that the black zones are not an issue with the RS-68A enabled 20% margin
  • ULA/NSF claim a 2014 Initial Operating Capability (IOC) date for Delta IV Heavy
  • ULA claims 4.5-years to IOC for Delta IV Heavy 
  • ULA says $800 million for a new pad, NSF said $750 million

Watching Pulliam’s presentation the significant points indicating that the report does not support the safety and other claims made by ULA/NSF are:

  • Pulliam said the report only looked at cost and schedule
  • Aero Corp says up to 7-years needed to realise human rated Delta IV Heavy 
  • And an extra year is needed for new Orion/Delta interfaces with a different upper stage

The Flame Trench blog post that Hyperbola has previously discussed was entitled Report: EELVs Could Safely Launch Orion but we now know that the Aerospace Corp study did not tackle safety, only “cost and schedule,” Pulliam’s own words

Augustine panel member and former astronaut Leroy Chiao asked Pulliam if a “PRA” had been carried out. Hyperbola has confirmed with Chiao that he was referring to loss of crew or loss of mission probabilistic risk assessment. Puliam’s answer was a no, confirming that the Aerospace Corporation study did not examine safety 

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned Seradata database. Trusted by over 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, Seradata is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

Gold rush for lunar comms attracts Lockheed Martin which sets up subsidiary to operate satellite relay pair

While landings on the Moon have been done before and are now regarded as a known technology, one aspect of Read more

Suspected maritime surveillance satellite Yaogan 34-04 sat launched by China

A Long March 4C (CZ-4C) launched from the Jiuquan Satellite Launch Center, China, at 0627 GMT on 31 March. The Read more

China launches four SAR satellites for commercial EO constellation

At 1050 GMT on 30 March a Long March 2D/2 (CZ-2D/2) rocket lifted-off from the Taiyuan Satellite Launch Center, China, Read more

SpaceX launches next batch of Starlink satellites: Group 5-10

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 from Cape Canaveral, USA at 2101 GMT on 29 March. The vehicle carried a Read more

Soyuz 2-1v single stack rocket launches fourth EO-MKA sat

At 1957 GMT on 29 March 2023, a Russian Soyuz-2-1v launch vehicle lifted off from the Plesetsk launch site in Read more

Space Insurance: Premium rates remain stable for now but underwriter sentiment turns against Arianespace

Twice a year, Seradata takes a survey of space underwriters to find out what typical premium rates are for rocket Read more

Damaged Soyuz MS-22 returns to Earth without its crew aboard

On 28 March 2023 the Roscosmos Soyuz MS-22/ISS-68S spacecraft undocked from the International Space Station (ISS) Rassvet module at 0957 Read more

Israel makes retrograde Shavit-2 launch of new Ofeq-13 satellite – believed to be for radar reconaissance

Israel has launched a Shavit-2 launch vehicle from the Palmachim launch site in Israel at circa 2110 GMT on 28 Read more




nasaspacexecoreviewsissesaArianespacevideochina25virgin galacticfalcon 9ULARoscosmosDGAaviation weekaresevasoyuzIGTspacewalkFalcon 9v1.2FT Block 5BeidouawardsInternational Space StationspaceSatellite broadcastingBlue OriginrussiamoonStarlinkCargo Return VehicleresearchboeingmarsblogAirbus DSOneWebRocket LaborionISROimpacthyperbolamarsdelayjaxaspaceshiptwodemocratgoogle lunar prizerocketlunarhypertextobamaEutelsatlaunchVegatourismconstellationbarack obamafiguresSESnorthspaceflightnode 2fundedthales alenia spaceRaymond LygoIntelsat2009romeAtlas VExpress MD-2dassault aviationss2Elon MuskLockheed MartinaviationLucy2008wk2sstlukradiotestmissilesuborbitaldocking portexplorationVirgin OrbitinternetChina Manned Space Engineeringsts-122Ariane 5 ECASLSmissile defensenewspapercotsgalileospace tourismflight2010Ariane 5Express AMU 1spaceportbuildspace stationaltairElectronshuttleProton Minternational astronautical congressNorthrop GrummanIntelsat 23Cosmosscaled compositesEuropean Space AgencyLauncherOnehanleybudgetrulesnew yorksoyuz 2-1aLong March 4CLong March 2D/2Ariane 6Vietnamatvspace shuttleshenzhoucongressMojaveboldeniacGuiana Space Centercnesnew shepardOrbital ATKLong March 2CUK Space AgencyksclawsSpace Systems/LoralUS Air ForceILSInmarsatLong March 4BprotonTalulah RileyApollodarpaeuSkylonAstriumlanderastronautbaseusapicturedragonSSLVega Cfiveeventlunar landerfalconSea LaunchWednesdayinterview50thSNCAprilKuaizhou 1ASpace InsuranceTelesat7customeratlantisLong Marchlinksuccessorgriffin