NASA responds to $300 million COTS question

by | Mar 3, 2010 | Seradata News | 3 comments

Mystery continues to surround the decision to add $300 million to NASA’s Commercial Orbital Transportation Services demonstration project (COTS) in the agency’s fiscal year 2011 budget request

During the 25 February US House of Representatives’ committee on science and technology’s space subcommittee NASA FY2011 budget request hearing (click here to watch the webcast) the space agency’s administrator Charles Bolden said that they decided more money was needed to realise cargo transport, that there are now companies that have come “in the last few months” that have said they could do it cheaper and that at the beginning of COTS the bidders had only been small firms, adding that “we are going to open a new round” of bidding

Hyperbola contacted NASA to ask about what Bolden had meant and what prospects there were for other companies to become part of COTS. But the agency has only responded with information (see full text of the response in the extended portion of this blog post) that is taken straight from the budget request text but with the caveat that nothing has been decided

However, considering aerospace projects tendency to take longer and cost more than originally projected it is likely that NASA will simply use the money to try to ensure the COTS companies, Space Exploration Technologies (SpaceX) and Orbital Sciences, deliver on the promised cargo transport capability next year as Space Shuttle is retired this year

SpaceX is already over two years late in the launching of its first COTS demonstration flight. That was planned for 2008 and its third flight was to have taken place by the end of last year. Orbital, which replaced Rocketplane-Kistler in early 2008, originally planned  its demo flight for the fourth quarter of this year but a NASA requirement change for a pressurised cargo module saw that launch pushed back to March 2011; a date which itself could come under threat

So we are left wondering what exactly Bolden meant by his references to a need for more money, a plan for new rounds of bidding, companies that claim they can do it cheaper and a sugegstion that larger aerospace companies could be involved in this apparent new phase

We are still in the planning stages regarding how the new money for COTS in FY11 will be used. It is possible that we could invest $312 million for incentivizing NASA’s current commercial cargo program to expedite the pace of development, add or accelerate the achievement of already-planned milestones and add additional capabilities or tests that may ultimately expedite the pace of development of cargo flights to the ISS and reduce risk. Risk reduction may include adding milestones to complete the Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) to identify early risks. Again, no decisions have been made on that or any of the other potential future COTS activities.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to

Related Articles

VIDEO: Senate NASA budget trequest hearing

Care of Spaceflight Now here is a video of the Senate commerce, science and transportation committee's science and space subcommittee Read more

Ares I is not dead: The Obama countdown to nowhere?

Is it going to be the 27 January state of the union address or will a 1 February statement accompanying Read more

Senator Nelson hearing shows they know they don’t know

If anything certain emerged out of the US Senate hearing (go here for archived webcast) yesterday it was that no Read more

Obama’s death panel for Constellation sees costs spiral

If Obama's 15 April Florida space conference wasn't a big enough opportunity for protests by locals then the fact that Read more

VIDEO: Senator LeMieux and others keep NASA potato hot

This report makes you wonder if Obama will face a Tea party, death panel like protest response to his forthcoming Read more

Bolden should know no plan survives contact with the enemy

Former US Marine Corp Major-General Charles Bolden must by now be reflecting upon the military axiom, no plan survives contact Read more

Will Fox news’ tea-parties get Obama and save Ares rockets?

Considering how NASA repeatedly fails to get any significant Congressional support for its programmes - president George Bush's failure to Read more

Cookies & Privacy

Click here to read about use of cookies on the website