Orbital Sciences sues ULA over RD-180 engine exclusivity clause

by | Jun 26, 2013 | commercial launch services, Russia, SLS | 0 comments

While Orbital Sciencs Corporation remains officially upbeat about its supply Russian NK-33 moon rocket engines avaialble to be refurbished to AJ-26 standard, it is known to be seeking a larger engine for later versions of its Antares launch vehicle.  In doing so, it found itself stymied by United Launch Alliance’s contractural exclusivity clause from getting its hands on the 933,000lb thrust RD Amross RD-180 engines which are more than twice as powerful as the 400,000lb thust AJ-26.  Space News reports that Orbital Sciences is now suing ULA over the issue, seeking damages of $515 million for an apparent restraint of trade under Sherman anti-trust laws.   The exclusivity clause is already under investigation by the US Federal Trade Commission.

The underpowered nature of the otherwise efficient NK-33 engines was the reason why the exotic N-1 moon rocket needed 30 of them for lift off.  Courtesy: Russian Federation/Wikipedia

Comment by David Todd:  There is one other alternative engine to the RD-180  the 1 million lb thrust AJ-1-E6 engine whose development Aerojet is partially being funded using SLS booster risk reduction money.   In truth however, there could be a long wait for its production as its development has really only just started with SLS money being used to “reduce the risk” of key elements of its design including its thrust chamber.

Actually, there is some suspicion over why the AJ-1-E6 engine is in the SLS programme at all.  Even at 1 million Ib thrust. this efficient oxygen-rich staged-combustion cycle engine would probably still not be enough for an SLS booster as four of them would probably be needed to be carried on each booster – a very uneconomic and high risk solution.  However an engine of this thrust class would be ideally sized for an Antares and its equivalent satellite launch vehicles.  Such a new engine could also help USA break away from using Russian licenced technology assuming it uses an all US design. So, in effect, while SLS “risk reduction” cash is probably doing good for the US rocket programme as a whole, if it will probablly not be as helpful to the SLS itself.

As it is, now that Rocketdyne is in the same stable as Aerojet, the firm’s 1.8 million lb thrust Saturn V derivative F-1B is thought to be a more likely choice if NASA plumps for a liquid fuel booster for SLS. While the F-1B uses a slightly less efficient gas generator cycle with a lower specific impulse than the AJ1-E-6 (ableit a much better one that a solid rocket design), this has less importance for booster spplications where lift-off thrust is king.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

SLS is delayed again by a hydrogen leak but repair allows another go…but when?

Having had its previous launch attempt on 29 August scrubbed by an engine temperature sensor issue, a second attempt to Read more

SLS maiden launch carrying Artemis I has first attempt scrubbed by engine sensor concern (Updated and corrected)

The much awaited first flight of the US SLS (Space Launch System) launch vehicle carrying the NASA Artemis I test Read more

NASA’s SLS heavy lift rocket is passed for lunar duty after completing curtailed fuelling and countdown test

NASA’s plans for unmanned and later human launches to the Moon have been given the green light to proceed after Read more

SLS Wet Dress Rehearsal is dogged by delays which eventually postpones it

The much delayed SLS Heavy-lift Launch Vehicle (HLV) due to take NASA astronauts back to the Moon won’t be going Read more

US$178 million Europa Clipper launch is formally awarded to SpaceX Falcon Heavy saving NASA US$2 billion

While NASA's US$4.25 billion Europa Clipper unmanned exploration flyby mission to Jupiter's moon Europa was always mooted as going on Read more

Analysis: You’re fired! Joe Biden beats Donald Trump in US Presidential Election…but what does this mean for Space?

After a record-breaking turnout and tense counts in swing states, Democrat challenger Joe Biden beat Republican incumbent President Donald Trump Read more

Pence commits NASA to human return to the Moon before 2024 as it goes cold on further development of SLS

The Trump Administration has signalled a change of space policy on a human return to the Moon. Addressing the National Space Read more

IAC 2018 Bremen: SLS future is assured for now as ICPS “tweak” improvements are planned alongside EUS upgrades

While the SLS Block I variant is nearly certain to achieve flight status, new heavy-lift rockets on the block threaten Read more