Review: ‘Interstellar’ is a sci-fi diamond but it has a few flaws

by | Nov 10, 2014 | exploration, History, Seradata News | 0 comments

‘Interstellar’ is a 2014 sci-fi movie directed by Christopher Nolan and starring Matthew McConaughey, Anne Hathaway, and Michael Caine, plus a surprise appearance from another well known actor.

The film’s relatively slow start is from the perspective of US farmers,  showing how mass dust bowls and induced crop failures are making it clear that in the near future mankind is doomed if it does not jump ship from this dying planet.  Thus an underground NASA and its clever team of scientists and engineers–types publicly decried in this future dystopia–concocts a multi-spacecraft mission to investigate possible destination planets in another galaxy.  Exactly how they get the huge development funding together, while managing to build a large interstellar explorer in orbit without being found out, remains just one of the film’s several unanswerable questions.

Interstellar’s expedition is led by Matthew McConaughey playing a former expert pilot reduced to farming for a living.  He, along with a super-smart science lady played by Anne Hathaway, and the rest of his small crew, head off in search of previous expeditions. The interstellar flight in question is made via a “wormhole” conveniently located next to a very photogenic planet Saturn.

Regular readers of our film reviews will probably now be expecting us to note the science fiction films that ‘Interstellar’ has apparently begged, borrowed and stolen from, or, at the very least, those that it has apparently been influenced by.  And so we shall. For on these shoulders of giants, ‘Interstellar’ stands.

These giants (well – actually some are just quite tall fellows) include: ‘When Worlds Collide’ (1951) – with its warning of impending disaster and the need to find another planet soon; ‘Contact’ (1997) – which describes the transportation possibilities of wormholes along with the weirdness associated with contacting alien life;  ‘2001 – A Space Odyssey’ (1968) for its psychedelic mysticism; the jeopardy thrills and beautiful imagery of ‘Sunshine’ (2007); and all teetering on the “edge of oblivion” as characterised in Disney’s ‘The Black Hole’ (1979).

There is also even a hint of the British long-lasting childhood-to-adult logging documentaries ‘7-Up’ et al as the effect of “relativity” on those left behind raises its aging head.  And, oh yes, some ungainly looking, but ultimately, very skilled and very loyal computerised robots, reminding one of the “good guy” computer in the never clone-alone mystery ‘Moon‘ (2009).

Interstellar‘ also references the actual Apollo moon landings, and rightly makes fools of those that deny them and try to rewrite history.  The film even uses what looks like an expendable Apollo-era Saturn V rocket to loft the main mission’s hi-tech reusable space landing ship into space–presumably launched from Earth in this ancient way in order to save fuel.

As for the spaceships themselves, well they also seem to have “parts from the past” including the triangular windows of the Apollo lunar module, and instrument panels from the Space Shuttle.  All this is then mixed up with reusable landing and interplanetary transfer hardware of a much higher order, making one wonder why all this old stuff is still on board?

Still, these are minor quibbles as it all makes for a great visual spectacle, and one that sticks more rigidly to known physics and astronautical science than the otherwise very good ‘Gravity‘ (2013).

But while this film starts off as an inter-galaxy action adventure movie, underneath this veneer there lies an enigmatic supernatural mystery that only those back on Earth can help solve. All will be revealed–in time and space. Well, if the laws of physics will let it.  But do not listen to Morrissey warbling on in the meantime.  For, by bizarre coincidence, the first three lyrical lines of The Smiths’ song, “A rush and a push and the land is ours”, seems to contain the solution.

So what is our verdict?  This sci-fi film does have a few flaws – a little too much sentimentality and too much “science for beginners” dialogue – albeit with some traces of original humour to sweeten the deal.  Nevertheless, this ‘Interstellar’ diamond remains an enthralling and intelligent movie…even if you probably need an astrophysics degree to see into its real beauty.

In summary, if you liked ‘Sunshine’ and ‘Gravity’, you will like this one even better.   Seradata’s Interstellar rating:  An excellent journey to infinity and beyond – 9 out of 10.

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

Maximum warp for AIAA book

I think this much used image originated with NASA but to read about the prospects for such transportation the American Read more

ULA Atlas V launch vehicle in “Lopsided” 511 configuration flies straight to put a pair of satellite GSSAP satellite snoopers into orbit

The Boeing/Lockheed Martin owned launch provider, the United Launch Alliance (ULA) which mainly specialises in US military launches, successfully launched Read more

SpaceX launches second Starlink mission of the year, 13 days after the first

SpaceX successfully launched a Falcon 9 rocket carrying 49 Starlink satellites from Kennedy Space Centre, Florida, USA. The flight lifted-off Read more

SpaceX launches first planned Transporter rideshare mission of 2022 carrying over 100 satellites

The SpaceX Transporter-3 rideshare mission launched from Cape Canaveral, Florida, at 1525 GMT, 13 January carrying over 100 satellites. The Read more

Russian cosmonauts make spacewalk to work on Prichal module as usual ISS raisings and departures go on

Russian cosmonauts Anton Shkaplerov, current commander of Expedition 66, and Peytr Dubrov, made a spacewalk from the International Space Station Read more

ESA confirms that Sentinel 1B’s radar is still knocked out by power issue

Sentinel-1B, a key Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) satellite of the ESA/EU Copernicus Earth observation and monitoring programme, has failed in Read more

Intelsat orders two further software-defined GEO sats, but this time from Thales

Intelsat has ordered two geostationary (GEO) satellites with new "software-defined payloads" from Thales Alenia Space (TAS). The contract announced on Read more

Tianzhou-2 freighter is remotely undocked and redocked with Chinese Space Station

Taikonauts (Chinese astronauts) aboard the Chinese Space Station (CSS) conducted a manual remote undocking involving the unberthing from the forward Read more

Categories

Archives

Tags