Why pro-robot space scientists should accept 2nd place

by | Dec 2, 2008 | Seradata News | 1 comment

jaxa 2a.JPG

credit: JAXA / caption: even frugal Japan is looking at human missions

After 50-years of robotic space science leading the way and the prospect of an orbital transportation system being stood up for less than the price of the development of the Airbus A380 you might think that space scientists should accept that the time has come for human’s to take the lead in scientific discovery of the solar system…

Hyperbola’s vision for space exploration part 2b will now be posted tomorrow 

The reality of science in general and space science in particular is that like a hobby horse every scientist believes that their research area should be give the mission/funding. I can understand that, its perfectly natural but it isn’t rational

It is almost too obvious to be worth stating that a small, solar panel, for example, powered computer with a small rocket engine and a number of scientific instruments specific to one of those heartfelt research areas is always going to be cheap, by comparison, to send off to the stars

It is also almost too obvious to be worth stating that the number of scientists and proposals that could be given spacecraft like this is so great they could consume the entire budgets of all the major space agencies combined

And this is my central point. There is never going to be enough money for space to satisfy the space scientists in the world and they and the entire argument about robots or people misses the main point

We humans want to explore those outer reaches ourselves, we want to go over the next hill, we want to see the Egyptian pyramids or the Sydney opera house for ourselves, not just see it in pictures, even high definition ones

And we have sent robotic probes to the furthest reaches of our solar system and beyond, and sadly to that excuse for a lump of ice that some want to call a planet for reasons that are beyond me – please excuse the anti-Pluto rant

So now as we stand on verge of an era that could see a privately developed manned spacecraft and other near-space access technologies, the argument should be that the cost, benefit analysis is in human beings’ favour 

The most obvious advantage of sending people is that the technology required to sustain them automatically enables more science to be done

I am not the first to push this argument and I won’t be the last but it is worth saying, and saying a lot, that it is plain to see that the payload capabilities of manned spacecraft automatically put them in a class of their own for doing space science when compared to the small robots we have traditionally sent

We don’t need another probe telling us the chemical composition of Jupiter’s atmosphere, we do need an endeavour that really will inspire, to see human beings walk over that next hill whether it be near Copernicus crater or Olympus Mons 

About Seradata

Seradata produce the renowned SpaceTrak Launch & Satellite Database. Trusted by 100 of the world’s leading Space organisations, SpaceTrak is a fully queryable database used for market analysis, failure/risk assessment, spectrum analysis and space situational awareness (SSA).

For more information go to www.seradata.com/spacetrak

Related Articles

PICTURE: Lockheed reveals Orion heat shield progress

Hyperbola didn't get its interview with Lockheed Martin Space Systems' human spaceflight vice president in the end and now the Read more

Canadian space exploration video game?

It seems NASA is not the first to develop a space exploration video game. While hunting around for new images Read more

News Bites go Global!

Go through to the extended portion of this blog post to read this edition of News Bites but for fun Read more

NASA administrator: Yes we can, oh no you don’t

Hyperbola is hearing that the process to select a candidate for NASA administrator is not just being held up by Read more

OFFICIAL: 2016 launch of pure-Russian ACTS

A prime contractor is to be picked for Russia's Advanced Crew Transportation System (ACTS) following a meeting of the Russian Read more

X-ROB: Europe’s €500,000 Moon and Mars robotic assembly study

The European Space Agency's Aurora core programme €500,000 ($640,000) EXploration Robotics Requirements and Concepts (X-ROB) study is investigating robots for Read more

TWITTER: Hyperbola’s live coverage of ESA chief’s press conference

Today, Wednesday 14 January, European Space Agency director general Jean-Jacques Dordain meets the media in his annual press conference. Read Read more

Three weeks to demand a UK astronaut

The UK goverment's coordinating body for government civil space activities, the British National Space Centre, has a space exploration review Read more